[U-Boot-Users] Atmel DataFlash hooks.

Grant Likely
2007-01-29T02:50:26Z

On 1/28/07, Wolfgang Denk <wd@denx.de> wrote:
> In message <45BD21D7.20203@comcast.net> you wrote:
> > What my goal in this proposed design is to allow users to choose at
> > compile time what features are desired for the u-boot memory commands
> > a) without an ifdef maze and b) without needing to inject new code into
> > cmd_mem.c and cmd_load.c for every different memory technology that will
> > use memory access type commands. If somebody wants to use the memory
> > commands on a serial EEPROM, this can be made to work if desired, or not
>
> I feel that would be not natural. And EEPROM (like on a I2C bus) does
> not have any natural adresses in the CPU's address space. Same for
> IDE or USB devices. These are storage devices on some form of I/O
> bus, but certainly NOT memory.

This is the exact category that MMC and DataFlash devices are in (both
accessed via SPI). Yet they are both accessible by commands in
cmd_mem.c.

> IMHO we should provide a user inteface which is powerful, yet easy to
> use - this requires it must be intuitive to the end user. For most f
> them, (NOR) flash *is* memory, while and IDE or USB disk and even an
> EEPROM is not.

Right; so what do we do with MMC and DataFlash?

g.

--
Grant Likely, B.Sc. P.Eng.
Secret Lab Technologies Ltd.
grant.likely at secretlab.ca
(403) 399-0195