[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[picmaster at mail.bg]

From: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>

Signed-off-by: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
---
 include/configs/embestmx6boards.h |    2 +-
 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-)

diff --git a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
index 185edbe..28099a8 100644
--- a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
+++ b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
@@ -120,7 +120,7 @@
 #define CONFIG_CMD_SETEXPR
 #undef CONFIG_CMD_IMLS
 
-#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               1
+#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               3
 
 #define CONFIG_LOADADDR                        0x12000000
 #define CONFIG_SYS_TEXT_BASE           0x17800000
-- 
1.7.10.4

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Eric Bénard]

Hi Nikolay,

Le Fri, 12 Dec 2014 20:16:19 +0200,
picmaster at mail.bg a ?crit :

> From: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
> 
> Signed-off-by: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
> ---
>  include/configs/embestmx6boards.h |    2 +-
>  1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-)
> 
> diff --git a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
> index 185edbe..28099a8 100644
> --- a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
> +++ b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
> @@ -120,7 +120,7 @@
>  #define CONFIG_CMD_SETEXPR
>  #undef CONFIG_CMD_IMLS
>  
> -#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               1
> +#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               3
>  
>  #define CONFIG_LOADADDR                        0x12000000
>  #define CONFIG_SYS_TEXT_BASE           0x17800000

This will increase the boot time by 2 seconds : why is that needed ?

Best regards,
Eric

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Michael Trimarchi]

Hi

On Sat, Dec 13, 2014 at 10:16 PM, Eric B?nard <eric@eukrea.com> wrote:
> Hi Nikolay,
>
> Le Fri, 12 Dec 2014 20:16:19 +0200,
> picmaster at mail.bg a ?crit :
>

Can you just change your enviroment? if I remember correctly you can
override boot delay

Michael

>> From: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
>>
>> Signed-off-by: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
>> ---
>>  include/configs/embestmx6boards.h |    2 +-
>>  1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-)
>>
>> diff --git a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
>> index 185edbe..28099a8 100644
>> --- a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
>> +++ b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
>> @@ -120,7 +120,7 @@
>>  #define CONFIG_CMD_SETEXPR
>>  #undef CONFIG_CMD_IMLS
>>
>> -#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               1
>> +#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               3
>>
>>  #define CONFIG_LOADADDR                        0x12000000
>>  #define CONFIG_SYS_TEXT_BASE           0x17800000
>
> This will increase the boot time by 2 seconds : why is that needed ?
>
> Best regards,
> Eric
> _______________________________________________
> U-Boot mailing list
> U-Boot at lists.denx.de
> http://lists.denx.de/mailman/listinfo/u-boot

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Nikolay Dimitrov]

Hi Michael,

On 12/13/2014 04:32 PM, Michael Trimarchi wrote:
> Hi
>
> On Sat, Dec 13, 2014 at 10:16 PM, Eric B?nard <eric@eukrea.com> wrote:
>> Hi Nikolay,
>>
>> Le Fri, 12 Dec 2014 20:16:19 +0200,
>> picmaster at mail.bg a ?crit :
>>
>
> Can you just change your enviroment? if I remember correctly you can
> override boot delay

Of course I can change the environment, but my point was towards
improving the default "out-of-the-box" behavior.

Kind regards,
Nikolay

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Michael Trimarchi]

Hi

Il 14/dic/2014 00:07 "Nikolay Dimitrov" <picmaster@mail.bg> ha scritto:
>
> Hi Michael,
>
>
> On 12/13/2014 04:32 PM, Michael Trimarchi wrote:
>>
>> Hi
>>
>> On Sat, Dec 13, 2014 at 10:16 PM, Eric B?nard <eric@eukrea.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> Hi Nikolay,
>>>
>>> Le Fri, 12 Dec 2014 20:16:19 +0200,
>>> picmaster at mail.bg a ?crit :
>>>
>>
>> Can you just change your enviroment? if I remember correctly you can
>> override boot delay
>
>
> Of course I can change the environment, but my point was towards
> improving the default "out-of-the-box" behavior.
>

I understand your point but I prefer a config option in configuration
instead of change it. I'm not have this board but most of the time I always
change something I don't like create my own environment or config.

Michael

> Kind regards,
> Nikolay

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Nikolay Dimitrov]

Hi Michael,

On 12/13/2014 06:14 PM, Michael Trimarchi wrote:
> Hi
>
> Il 14/dic/2014 00:07 "Nikolay Dimitrov" <picmaster@mail.bg
> <mailto:picmaster@mail.bg>> ha scritto:
>  >
>  > Hi Michael,
>  >
>  >
>  > On 12/13/2014 04:32 PM, Michael Trimarchi wrote:
>  >>
>  >> Hi
>  >>
>  >> On Sat, Dec 13, 2014 at 10:16 PM, Eric B?nard <eric@eukrea.com
> <mailto:eric@eukrea.com>> wrote:
>  >>>
>  >>> Hi Nikolay,
>  >>>
>  >>> Le Fri, 12 Dec 2014 20:16:19 +0200,
>  >>> picmaster at mail.bg <mailto:picmaster@mail.bg> a ?crit :
>  >>>
>  >>
>  >> Can you just change your enviroment? if I remember correctly you can
>  >> override boot delay
>  >
>  >
>  > Of course I can change the environment, but my point was towards
>  > improving the default "out-of-the-box" behavior.
>  >
>
> I understand your point but I prefer a config option in configuration
> instead of change it. I'm not have this board but most of the time I
> always change something I don't like create my own environment or config.

Well, the "bootdelay" env-var is still there, so everyone can take
advantage of it.

I have both RIoTboard & MarsBoard, and my practical experience with
them motivated me to propose this optimisation of the default U-Boot
behavior.

Kind regards,
Nikolay

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Nikolay Dimitrov]

Hi Eric,

On 12/13/2014 04:16 PM, Eric B?nard wrote:
> Hi Nikolay,
>
> Le Fri, 12 Dec 2014 20:16:19 +0200,
> picmaster at mail.bg a ?crit :
>
>> From: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
>>
>> Signed-off-by: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
>> ---
>>   include/configs/embestmx6boards.h |    2 +-
>>   1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-)
>>
>> diff --git a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
>> index 185edbe..28099a8 100644
>> --- a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
>> +++ b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
>> @@ -120,7 +120,7 @@
>>   #define CONFIG_CMD_SETEXPR
>>   #undef CONFIG_CMD_IMLS
>>
>> -#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               1
>> +#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               3
>>
>>   #define CONFIG_LOADADDR                        0x12000000
>>   #define CONFIG_SYS_TEXT_BASE           0x17800000
>
> This will increase the boot time by 2 seconds : why is that needed ?

Thanks for commenting. My intent is to give by default a reasonable
time for the end-user to react and break the boot-sequence if needed
(and avoid the nasty racing against the clock for this precious
key-press).

My motivation for this is that I see RIoTboard/MarsBoard mostly as
boards that people can use for experimentation/prototyping, and not as
a finished end-product, thus my thinking that the slightly increased
boot-time won't be a critical issue for such applications. Still
everyone can change the delay at will if they want to optimize the boot.

Other hobby boards also have similarly handy boot-timings, like
Wandboard (5s), Novena (5s), Udoo (3s).

Kind regards,
Nikolay

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Eric Bénard]

Hi Nikolay,

Le Sat, 13 Dec 2014 18:05:15 +0200,
Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg> a ?crit :
> On 12/13/2014 04:16 PM, Eric B?nard wrote:
> > Le Fri, 12 Dec 2014 20:16:19 +0200,
> > picmaster at mail.bg a ?crit :
> >
> >> From: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
> >>
> >> Signed-off-by: Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg>
> >> ---
> >>   include/configs/embestmx6boards.h |    2 +-
> >>   1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-)
> >>
> >> diff --git a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
> >> index 185edbe..28099a8 100644
> >> --- a/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
> >> +++ b/include/configs/embestmx6boards.h
> >> @@ -120,7 +120,7 @@
> >>   #define CONFIG_CMD_SETEXPR
> >>   #undef CONFIG_CMD_IMLS
> >>
> >> -#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               1
> >> +#define CONFIG_BOOTDELAY               3
> >>
> >>   #define CONFIG_LOADADDR                        0x12000000
> >>   #define CONFIG_SYS_TEXT_BASE           0x17800000
> >
> > This will increase the boot time by 2 seconds : why is that needed ?
> 
> Thanks for commenting. My intent is to give by default a reasonable
> time for the end-user to react and break the boot-sequence if needed
> (and avoid the nasty racing against the clock for this precious
> key-press).
> 
> My motivation for this is that I see RIoTboard/MarsBoard mostly as
> boards that people can use for experimentation/prototyping, and not as
> a finished end-product, thus my thinking that the slightly increased
> boot-time won't be a critical issue for such applications. Still
> everyone can change the delay at will if they want to optimize the boot.
> 
> Other hobby boards also have similarly handy boot-timings, like
> Wandboard (5s), Novena (5s), Udoo (3s).
> 
OK seems reasonable.

Eric

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Iain Paton]

On 13/12/14 17:03, Eric B?nard wrote:
> Hi Nikolay,
> 
> Le Sat, 13 Dec 2014 18:05:15 +0200,
> Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg> a ?crit :
>> On 12/13/2014 04:16 PM, Eric B?nard wrote:

>>> This will increase the boot time by 2 seconds : why is that needed ?
>>
>> Thanks for commenting. My intent is to give by default a reasonable
>> time for the end-user to react and break the boot-sequence if needed
>> (and avoid the nasty racing against the clock for this precious
>> key-press).
>>
>> My motivation for this is that I see RIoTboard/MarsBoard mostly as
>> boards that people can use for experimentation/prototyping, and not as
>> a finished end-product, thus my thinking that the slightly increased
>> boot-time won't be a critical issue for such applications. Still
>> everyone can change the delay at will if they want to optimize the boot.
>>
>> Other hobby boards also have similarly handy boot-timings, like
>> Wandboard (5s), Novena (5s), Udoo (3s).
>>
> OK seems reasonable.

I disagree. I think it's an unnecessary, unneeded, unreasonable tripling 
of the boot time.

Rather than leaving people to patch out this unwanted behaviour, I'd suggest 
promoting CONFIG_BOOTDELAY into a Kconfig option, leaving the default as-is.

This allows the people who want it to configure it easily.

In any case the rationale given, that the Riotboard is a dev board used for
experimenting, doesn't imply a change like this one. It implies a conversion 
to use config_distro_bootcmd.h like the patches I've just posted.
This also leads to a slightly less unreasonable increase in bootdelay to 2s 
from config_distro_defaults.h

Using config_distro_bootcmd also means that we can largely ignore the u-boot 
shell altogether and just use extlinux.conf instead

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Michael Trimarchi]

Hi

On Sun, Dec 14, 2014 at 10:52 PM, Iain Paton <ipaton0@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 13/12/14 17:03, Eric B?nard wrote:
>> Hi Nikolay,
>>
>> Le Sat, 13 Dec 2014 18:05:15 +0200,
>> Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg> a ?crit :
>>> On 12/13/2014 04:16 PM, Eric B?nard wrote:
>
>>>> This will increase the boot time by 2 seconds : why is that needed ?
>>>
>>> Thanks for commenting. My intent is to give by default a reasonable
>>> time for the end-user to react and break the boot-sequence if needed
>>> (and avoid the nasty racing against the clock for this precious
>>> key-press).
>>>
>>> My motivation for this is that I see RIoTboard/MarsBoard mostly as
>>> boards that people can use for experimentation/prototyping, and not as
>>> a finished end-product, thus my thinking that the slightly increased
>>> boot-time won't be a critical issue for such applications. Still
>>> everyone can change the delay at will if they want to optimize the boot.
>>>
>>> Other hobby boards also have similarly handy boot-timings, like
>>> Wandboard (5s), Novena (5s), Udoo (3s).
>>>
>> OK seems reasonable.
>
> I disagree. I think it's an unnecessary, unneeded, unreasonable tripling
> of the boot time.
>
> Rather than leaving people to patch out this unwanted behaviour, I'd suggest
> promoting CONFIG_BOOTDELAY into a Kconfig option, leaving the default as-is.
>

I'm agree and this is what I say in my previous email

Michael

> This allows the people who want it to configure it easily.
>
> In any case the rationale given, that the Riotboard is a dev board used for
> experimenting, doesn't imply a change like this one. It implies a conversion
> to use config_distro_bootcmd.h like the patches I've just posted.
> This also leads to a slightly less unreasonable increase in bootdelay to 2s
> from config_distro_defaults.h
>
> Using config_distro_bootcmd also means that we can largely ignore the u-boot
> shell altogether and just use extlinux.conf instead
> _______________________________________________
> U-Boot mailing list
> U-Boot at lists.denx.de
> http://lists.denx.de/mailman/listinfo/u-boot



-- 
| Michael Nazzareno Trimarchi                     Amarula Solutions BV |
| COO  -  Founder                                      Cruquiuskade 47 |
| +31(0)851119172                                 Amsterdam 1018 AM NL |
|                  [`as] http://www.amarulasolutions.com               |

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Nikolay Dimitrov]

Hi Iain,

On 12/14/2014 04:52 PM, Iain Paton wrote:
> On 13/12/14 17:03, Eric B?nard wrote:
>> Hi Nikolay,
>>
>> Le Sat, 13 Dec 2014 18:05:15 +0200,
>> Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg> a ?crit :
>>> On 12/13/2014 04:16 PM, Eric B?nard wrote:
>
>>>> This will increase the boot time by 2 seconds : why is that needed ?
>>>
>>> Thanks for commenting. My intent is to give by default a reasonable
>>> time for the end-user to react and break the boot-sequence if needed
>>> (and avoid the nasty racing against the clock for this precious
>>> key-press).
>>>
>>> My motivation for this is that I see RIoTboard/MarsBoard mostly as
>>> boards that people can use for experimentation/prototyping, and not as
>>> a finished end-product, thus my thinking that the slightly increased
>>> boot-time won't be a critical issue for such applications. Still
>>> everyone can change the delay at will if they want to optimize the boot.
>>>
>>> Other hobby boards also have similarly handy boot-timings, like
>>> Wandboard (5s), Novena (5s), Udoo (3s).
>>>
>> OK seems reasonable.
>
> I disagree. I think it's an unnecessary, unneeded, unreasonable tripling
> of the boot time.

I have 2 things to say about this:
1. In theory we can also question why the initial boot delay was 
selected to be 1s.
2. You imply that the "users" want ultra-fast boot times for riotboard. 
Being myself one of the riotboard users, I can assure you that such 
generalization is excessive.

> Rather than leaving people to patch out this unwanted behaviour, I'd suggest
> promoting CONFIG_BOOTDELAY into a Kconfig option, leaving the default as-is.

This is a good idea in general, I don't mind it.

> This also leads to a slightly less unreasonable increase in bootdelay to 2s
> from config_distro_defaults.h

Well, this is again subjective - we can always argue that 2s is both too 
long and too short for selected use cases, so I don't understand the 
qualification "less unreasonable".

In summary - I won't carry a war for this change, as it doesn't worth 
it. I just tried to contribute a tiny bit of improvement to the already 
excellent work of Eric, so we can have a silk-smooth out-of-the-box 
U-Boot user experience, and I'm doing this as an actual riotboard user. 
That's all.

Thanks for sharing your viewpoint.

Kind regards,
Nikolay

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Eric Bénard]

Le Sun, 14 Dec 2014 22:56:21 +0200,
Nikolay Dimitrov <picmaster@mail.bg> a ?crit :
> On 12/14/2014 04:52 PM, Iain Paton wrote:
> > This also leads to a slightly less unreasonable increase in bootdelay to 2s
> > from config_distro_defaults.h
> 
> Well, this is again subjective - we can always argue that 2s is both too 
> long and too short for selected use cases, so I don't understand the 
> qualification "less unreasonable".
> 
> In summary - I won't carry a war for this change, as it doesn't worth 
> it. I just tried to contribute a tiny bit of improvement to the already 
> excellent work of Eric, so we can have a silk-smooth out-of-the-box 
> U-Boot user experience, and I'm doing this as an actual riotboard user. 
> That's all.
> 
well if Iain's patch configure the bootdelay to 2 seconds by default
this will be a perfect average between the actual state and your
proposal so I suggest you test Iain's patch and if its OK for you send
your ack as I have no time to test on Riot or Mars board before next
year ;-)

Thanks !
Eric

[U-Boot] [PATCH] embestmx6boards: Increase boot delay to 3s

[Iain Paton]

On 14/12/14 20:56, Nikolay Dimitrov wrote:

> In summary - I won't carry a war for this change, as it doesn't worth 
> it. I just tried to contribute a tiny bit of improvement to the already 
> excellent work of Eric, so we can have a silk-smooth out-of-the-box 
> U-Boot user experience, and I'm doing this as an actual riotboard user. 
> That's all.

I'm a riotboard user too, and have contributed towards it's success in my 
own ways. The choice of 1s hasn't been a problem for the many people using 
the Debian images I provided.

Anyway, it's in the interest of Riot/Mars to move towards the 
config_distro_* way of doing things longer term as it's likely to gain
easy support by the general distros that way.

Assuming those patches get accepted, the bootdelay ends up in the 
common config shared by all boards using config_distro_defaults. 
Over time I suspect that's likely to include most of the general dev 
boards.

It's still likely to be worth moving it to Kconfig as both of us will 
probably want to change it to our own preferences regardless :)