Re: [PATCH 0/10] af_unix: add multicast and filtering features to AF_UNIX

[Rodrigo Moya <rodrigo.moya@collabora.co.uk>]

Hi Erik

On Thu, 2012-03-01 at 15:25 +0100, Erik Hugne wrote:
> Hi
> Have you considered using TIPC instead?
> It already provides multicast messaging with guaranteed ordering, and reliable delivery  (SOCK _RDM)
> 
I didn't know about TIPC, so have been having a quick look over it, and
have some questions about it:

* since it's for cluster use, I guess it's based on AF_INET sockets? if
so, see the messages from Luis Augusto and Javier about this breaking
current D-Bus apps, that use fd passing, for out-of-band data

* D-Bus works locally, with all processes on the same machine, but there
are 2 buses (daemons), one for system-related interfaces, and one per
user, so how would this work with TIPC. Can you create several
clusters/networks (as in TIPC addressing semantics) on the same machine
on the loopback device?

* I installed tipcutils on my machine, and it asked me if I wanted to
setup the machine as a TIPC node. Does this mean every machine needs to
be setup as a TIPC node before any app makes use of it? That is, can I
just create a AF_TIPC socket on this machine and just make it work
without any further setup?

* I guess it is easy to prevent any TIPC-enabled machine to get into the
local communication channel, right? That is, what's the security
mechanism for allowing local-only communications?

I'll stop asking questions and have a deeper look at it :)