Re: Major XFS problems...

[Nathan Scott <nathans@sgi.com>]

Hi there,

On Wed, Sep 08, 2004 at 02:35:24PM +0200, Jakob Oestergaard wrote:
> 
> First XFS bug:
> ---------------
> http://oss.sgi.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=309
> 
> Submitted in februrary this year - requires server reboot, NFS clients
> will then re-trigger the bug immediately after the NFS server is started
> again.  Clearly not a pleasent problem.
> 
> A fairly simple patch is available, which solves the problem in the most
> common cases.  This simple patch has *not*yet* been included in 2.6.8.1.
> 

Have you asked Christoph if he thinks that patch is ready for
inclusion?  Its possibly just fallen through the cracks.

> Second XFS bug:
> ---------------
> Also causes the 'kernel BUG at fs/xfs/support/debug.c:106' message to be
> printed. This bug is not solved by applying the simple patch to the
> first problem.
> 
> How well known this problem is, I don't know - I can get more details on
> this if anyone is actually interested in working on fixing XFS.

Yes please (it does help to actually contact the maintainers when
reporting bugs...).  It is not well known.

> Third XFS bug:
> --------------
> XFS causes lowmem oom, triggering the OOM killer. Reported by
> as@cohaesio.com on the 18th of august.
> 
> On the 24th of august, William Lee Irwin gives some suggestions and
> mentions  "xfs has some known bad slab behavior."

Hmm?  Which message was that?

> ...
> While the small server seems to be running well now, the large one has
> an average uptime of about one day (!)   Backups will crash it reliably,
> when XFS doesn't OOM the box at random.

It would be a good idea to track the memory statistics while you're
running your workloads to see where in particular the memory is being
used when you hit OOM - /proc/{meminfo,slabinfo,buddyinfo}.  I'd also
be interested to hear if that vfs_cache_pressure tweak that someone
recommended helps your load at all, thanks.

Is this xfsdump you're running for backups?

> Is anyone actually maintaining/bugfixing XFS?

Yes, there's a group of people actively working on it.

> Yes, I know the MAINTAINERS file,

But haven't figured out how to use it yet?

> ...
> trivial-to-trigger bugs that crash the system and have simple fixes,
> have not been fixed in current mainline kernels.

If you have trivial-to-trigger bugs (or other bugs) then please let
the folks at linux-xfs@oss.sgi.com know all the details (test cases,
etc, are quite useful).

cheers.

-- 
Nathan