closedlistsub not working

closedlistsub not working

[Magnus Naeslund(k)]

Hello,
I'm a qmail defector that is evaluating mlmmj to be used with a postfix
installation instead of ezmlm + qmail. We might be moving quite a number
of lists over to mlmmj if the evaluation is positive.

When i tried to enable "closedlistsub" it still enables me to subscribe,
has anyone seen this before?

Also I would be very happy if someone could help me with this:

I'm trying to map the different types of ezmlm lists we provide over to
the mlmmj options. These are the types of ezmlm list we have now:

announcelist_modsub:
	A list that is moderated in two ways,
	subscription requests are sent to moderator(s),
	posts are also sent to moderators for approval.

announcelist:
	Anyone can subscribe, but posts go to moderators.

priv_privpost:
	Private list that only moderators can approve on
	subscription requests.
	Only subscribers can post.

priv_pubpost:
	Private list that only moderators can approve on
	subscription requests, but anyone can post to the list.
	
pubsub: the normal kind of public list, anyone can post to it

I know that most of these should be easy with mlmmj, but some of them I
can't really map. Any pointers are appreciated.

Regards,
Magnus Naeslund

Re: closedlistsub not working

[Magnus Naeslund(k)]

Magnus Naeslund wrote:
> Hello,

Oh, I forgot to mention the mlmmj version used, it's a ubuntu (hence
debian) package, version 1.2.9-1.

Regards,
Magnus

Re: closedlistsub not working

[Mads Martin Joergensen]

* Magnus Naeslund(k) <mag@kite.se> [Aug 06. 2006 03:39]:
> Magnus Naeslund wrote:
> > Hello,
> 
> Oh, I forgot to mention the mlmmj version used, it's a ubuntu (hence
> debian) package, version 1.2.9-1.

That explains it :)

Look at ChangeLog:

1.2.10
 o Fix nasty bug in the new 1.2.9 find_email_adr() making comma in
   quoted text in From: being discarded as invalid
 o Simply make all addresses lowercase before doing anything else
   wrt. sub/unsub and bounce
 o Add czech listtexts (Lukas Hluze)
 o Make non list emails (subconf, moderation etc.) also honor relayhost
   and smtpport
 o Add tunable to be able to close for subscription only (closedlistsub)

'closedlistsub' was added in 1.2.10.

-- 
Mads Martin Joergensen, http://mmj.dk
"Why make things difficult, when it is possible to make them cryptic
 and totally illogical, with just a little bit more effort?"
                                 -- A. P. J.

Re: closedlistsub not working

[Mads Martin Joergensen]

* Magnus Naeslund(k) <mag@kite.se> [Aug 06. 2006 03:33]:
> Hello,
> I'm a qmail defector that is evaluating mlmmj to be used with a postfix
> installation instead of ezmlm + qmail. We might be moving quite a number
> of lists over to mlmmj if the evaluation is positive.
> 
> When i tried to enable "closedlistsub" it still enables me to subscribe,
> has anyone seen this before?

See my other posting to the list.

> Also I would be very happy if someone could help me with this:
> 
> I'm trying to map the different types of ezmlm lists we provide over to
> the mlmmj options. These are the types of ezmlm list we have now:
> 
> announcelist_modsub:
> 	A list that is moderated in two ways,
> 	subscription requests are sent to moderator(s),
> 	posts are also sent to moderators for approval.
> 
> announcelist:
> 	Anyone can subscribe, but posts go to moderators.
> 
> priv_privpost:
> 	Private list that only moderators can approve on
> 	subscription requests.
> 	Only subscribers can post.
> 
> priv_pubpost:
> 	Private list that only moderators can approve on
> 	subscription requests, but anyone can post to the list.
> 	
> pubsub: the normal kind of public list, anyone can post to it
> 
> I know that most of these should be easy with mlmmj, but some of them I
> can't really map. Any pointers are appreciated.

If I could just get myself together and finish moderated subscription
(80% done) once more (previous implementation got lost with my previous
laptop) all of the above will be possible.

Maybe it really is time to get this out of my hair, and take another
stab at it tonight. Last time I finished it and it was working, it was
just a matter of a couple of hours...

-- 
Mads Martin Joergensen, http://mmj.dk
"Why make things difficult, when it is possible to make them cryptic
 and totally illogical, with just a little bit more effort?"
                                 -- A. P. J.

Re: closedlistsub not working

[Christian Lackas]

* Mads Martin Joergensen <mmj@mmj.dk> [060806 09:57]:

Hi Mads,

> If I could just get myself together and finish moderated subscription
> (80% done) once more (previous implementation got lost with my
> previous laptop) all of the above will be possible.

hope I am not asking for too much, however, I just have the case that I
need a list where mails of subscribers are send out directly and all
other mails go into the moderation queue.
Maybe, if you working in this area anyway... :-)

Thanks for a great program,
 Christian

-- 
http://www.lackas.net/                  http://www.spect-ct.com/