[Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): No RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): No RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jonas Witt]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1327 bytes --]

Hi everybody,

 

i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a while
now..

 

I have tried different programs like
http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php

 

I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer). Opening
a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also writing.
The Problem stems from the call to:

 

rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);

 

which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at least
_something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is working
fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls to
rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really be
emphasized in the documentation..)

 

I am already pretty much behind my schedule with the project that i am
undertaking.. any (preferably fast ;) ) input is very much appreciated. I
think i will update the serial driver documentation when i am through with
my initial problems. I think that is desperately needed for other people
that are new to xenomai.

 

Thanks in advance!

Cheers, Jonas


[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 4479 bytes --]

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): NoRTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jonas Witt]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> > Hi everybody,
> > 
> >  
> > 
> > i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a while
> > now..
> > 
> >  
> > 
> > I have tried different programs like
> > http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
> > 
> >  
> > 
> > I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
> > writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer).
Opening
> > a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also
writing.
> > The Problem stems from the call to:
> > 
> >  
> > 
> > rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
> > 
> >  
> > 
> > which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
> > self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at >
least
> > _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is
working
> > fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls to
> > rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really be
> > emphasized in the documentation..)
> > 
>
> Some suggestions:
>
>  o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
>    xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong
>
>  o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
>    on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may be
>    wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
>    broken.
>
>  o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues (hardware
>    gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)
>
> Jan

Thanks for the fast reply!

I am using the following kernel parameters:

kernel		/boot/vmlinuz-2.6.19-ipipe root=/dev/sda1 ro 8250.nr_uarts=0
xeno_16550A.ioaddr=0x3f8 xeno_16550A.irq=4

I got these settings from setserial prior to disabling the kernel-driver. To
be honest i don't know how to 'check' /proc/xenomai/irq for progress. I took
a look at the folder prior to and while running my modified cross-link-code
but irq is an empty file in both cases. Is there some special trick/function
to handle the files in the proc-folder?

To the last point.. so there is an updated version of the driver available?
I think i will try that one.. is it just a question of executing 'make' and
modprobing or are there more actions involved?

Best regards,
Jonas

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): NoRTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jonas Witt]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>> Hi everybody,
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a while
>>> now..
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> I have tried different programs like
>>> http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
>>> writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer).
> Opening
>>> a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also
> writing.
>>> The Problem stems from the call to:
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
>>> self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at >
> least
>>> _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is
> working
>>> fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls to
>>> rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really be
>>> emphasized in the documentation..)
>>>
>> Some suggestions:
>>
>>  o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
>>    xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong
>>
>>  o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
>>    on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may be
>>    wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
>>    broken.
>>
>>  o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues (hardware
>>    gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)
>>
>> Jan
>> 
>> Thanks for the fast reply!
>> 
>> I am using the following kernel parameters:
>> 
>> kernel		/boot/vmlinuz-2.6.19-ipipe root=/dev/sda1 ro
8250.nr_uarts=0
>> xeno_16550A.ioaddr=0x3f8 xeno_16550A.irq=4
>>
>OK, that leads to another suggestion: try going the modular path for
>xeno_16550A first, it's the more common one. Above /should/ be no
>problem /wrt the the RT driver, but kicking 8250 out of the game could
>cause that PnP power issue I sketched.
>
>> 
>> I got these settings from setserial prior to disabling the kernel-driver.
To
>> be honest i don't know how to 'check' /proc/xenomai/irq for progress. I
took
>> a look at the folder prior to and while running my modified
cross-link-code
>> but irq is an empty file in both cases. Is there some special
trick/function
>> to handle the files in the proc-folder?
>
>You mean the file is existing but empty??? That would be fairly uncommon.
>
>(without any driver loaded)
># cat /proc/xenomai/irq
>IRQ         CPU0
>217:           0
>226:           0         [virtual]
>
>The serial driver pops up here once the port is opened. The per-cpu irq
>hit counter should then increase as interrupts come in.
>
>> 
>> To the last point.. so there is an updated version of the driver
>available?
>> I think i will try that one.. is it just a question of executing 'make'
>and
>> modprobing or are there more actions involved?
>
>No, it's not that easy (more files, changed Makefiles and RTDM API).
>First try the modular driver path, ie. keep 8250, switch off the Linux
>port with setserial, and load the RT driver as a module. Then, if this
>doesn't help, you could consider upgrading your Xenomai installation (at
>least for a test) to SVN trunk.
>
>Jan

Ah, ok.. ehem... i tried to look at the file with gedit.. and it displays
nothing.. ;)
Now i get:

IRQ         CPU0
  4:           0         rtser0
216:         521         [timer]
226:         620         [virtual]

This is how it looks like after the program starts.. after that it increases
just the [virtual] and the [timer] counter . Rtser0 stays at 0 all the time
(although information is successfully written to the port, judging from the
return value of rt_dev_write).

So i guess that is where the problem lies.. what can I do about that?

Jonas

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): No RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jan Kiszka]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1547 bytes --]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> Hi everybody,
> 
>  
> 
> i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a while
> now..
> 
>  
> 
> I have tried different programs like
> http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
> 
>  
> 
> I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
> writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer). Opening
> a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also writing.
> The Problem stems from the call to:
> 
>  
> 
> rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
> 
>  
> 
> which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
> self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at least
> _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is working
> fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls to
> rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really be
> emphasized in the documentation..)
> 

Some suggestions:

 o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
   xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong

 o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
   on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may be
   wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
   broken.

 o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues (hardware
   gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)

Jan


[-- Attachment #2: OpenPGP digital signature --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 250 bytes --]

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): NoRTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jan Kiszka]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 3378 bytes --]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>> Hi everybody,
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a while
>>> now..
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> I have tried different programs like
>>> http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
>>> writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer).
> Opening
>>> a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also
> writing.
>>> The Problem stems from the call to:
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>> which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
>>> self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at >
> least
>>> _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is
> working
>>> fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls to
>>> rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really be
>>> emphasized in the documentation..)
>>>
>> Some suggestions:
>>
>>  o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
>>    xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong
>>
>>  o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
>>    on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may be
>>    wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
>>    broken.
>>
>>  o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues (hardware
>>    gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)
>>
>> Jan
> 
> Thanks for the fast reply!
> 
> I am using the following kernel parameters:
> 
> kernel		/boot/vmlinuz-2.6.19-ipipe root=/dev/sda1 ro 8250.nr_uarts=0
> xeno_16550A.ioaddr=0x3f8 xeno_16550A.irq=4

OK, that leads to another suggestion: try going the modular path for
xeno_16550A first, it's the more common one. Above /should/ be no
problem /wrt the the RT driver, but kicking 8250 out of the game could
cause that PnP power issue I sketched.

> 
> I got these settings from setserial prior to disabling the kernel-driver. To
> be honest i don't know how to 'check' /proc/xenomai/irq for progress. I took
> a look at the folder prior to and while running my modified cross-link-code
> but irq is an empty file in both cases. Is there some special trick/function
> to handle the files in the proc-folder?

You mean the file is existing but empty??? That would be fairly uncommon.

(without any driver loaded)
# cat /proc/xenomai/irq
IRQ         CPU0
217:           0
226:           0         [virtual]

The serial driver pops up here once the port is opened. The per-cpu irq
hit counter should then increase as interrupts come in.

> 
> To the last point.. so there is an updated version of the driver available?
> I think i will try that one.. is it just a question of executing 'make' and
> modprobing or are there more actions involved?

No, it's not that easy (more files, changed Makefiles and RTDM API).
First try the modular driver path, ie. keep 8250, switch off the Linux
port with setserial, and load the RT driver as a module. Then, if this
doesn't help, you could consider upgrading your Xenomai installation (at
least for a test) to SVN trunk.

Jan


[-- Attachment #2: OpenPGP digital signature --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 250 bytes --]

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): NoRTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jan Kiszka]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 4286 bytes --]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> Jonas Witt wrote:
>> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>>> Hi everybody,
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a while
>>>> now..
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> I have tried different programs like
>>>> http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
>>>> writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer).
>> Opening
>>>> a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also
>> writing.
>>>> The Problem stems from the call to:
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
>>>> self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at >
>> least
>>>> _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is
>> working
>>>> fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls to
>>>> rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really be
>>>> emphasized in the documentation..)
>>>>
>>> Some suggestions:
>>>
>>>  o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
>>>    xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong
>>>
>>>  o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
>>>    on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may be
>>>    wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
>>>    broken.
>>>
>>>  o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues (hardware
>>>    gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)
>>>
>>> Jan
>>>
>>> Thanks for the fast reply!
>>>
>>> I am using the following kernel parameters:
>>>
>>> kernel		/boot/vmlinuz-2.6.19-ipipe root=/dev/sda1 ro
> 8250.nr_uarts=0
>>> xeno_16550A.ioaddr=0x3f8 xeno_16550A.irq=4
>>>
>> OK, that leads to another suggestion: try going the modular path for
>> xeno_16550A first, it's the more common one. Above /should/ be no
>> problem /wrt the the RT driver, but kicking 8250 out of the game could
>> cause that PnP power issue I sketched.
>>
>>> I got these settings from setserial prior to disabling the kernel-driver.
> To
>>> be honest i don't know how to 'check' /proc/xenomai/irq for progress. I
> took
>>> a look at the folder prior to and while running my modified
> cross-link-code
>>> but irq is an empty file in both cases. Is there some special
> trick/function
>>> to handle the files in the proc-folder?
>> You mean the file is existing but empty??? That would be fairly uncommon.
>>
>> (without any driver loaded)
>> # cat /proc/xenomai/irq
>> IRQ         CPU0
>> 217:           0
>> 226:           0         [virtual]
>>
>> The serial driver pops up here once the port is opened. The per-cpu irq
>> hit counter should then increase as interrupts come in.
>>
>>> To the last point.. so there is an updated version of the driver
>> available?
>>> I think i will try that one.. is it just a question of executing 'make'
>> and
>>> modprobing or are there more actions involved?
>> No, it's not that easy (more files, changed Makefiles and RTDM API).
>> First try the modular driver path, ie. keep 8250, switch off the Linux
>> port with setserial, and load the RT driver as a module. Then, if this
>> doesn't help, you could consider upgrading your Xenomai installation (at
>> least for a test) to SVN trunk.
>>
>> Jan
> 
> Ah, ok.. ehem... i tried to look at the file with gedit.. and it displays
> nothing.. ;)
> Now i get:
> 
> IRQ         CPU0
>   4:           0         rtser0
> 216:         521         [timer]
> 226:         620         [virtual]
> 
> This is how it looks like after the program starts.. after that it increases
> just the [virtual] and the [timer] counter . Rtser0 stays at 0 all the time
> (although information is successfully written to the port, judging from the
> return value of rt_dev_write).
> 
> So i guess that is where the problem lies.. what can I do about that?

Apply the other suggestion I made. You may try to talk to a dead device
if 8250 is not loaded and takes over the PnP work.

Jan


[-- Attachment #2: OpenPGP digital signature --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 250 bytes --]

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver(rtser): No RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jonas Witt]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> Jonas Witt wrote:
>> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>>> Hi everybody,
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a
while
>>>> now..
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> I have tried different programs like
>>>> http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
>>>> writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer).
>> Opening
>>>> a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also
>> writing.
>>>> The Problem stems from the call to:
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
>>>>
>>>>  
>>>>
>>>> which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
>>>> self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at
>
>> least
>>>> _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is
>> working
>>>> fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls to
>>>> rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really be
>>>> emphasized in the documentation..)
>>>>
>>> Some suggestions:
>>>
>>>  o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
>>>    xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong
>>>
>>>  o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
>>>    on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may be
>>>    wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
>>>    broken.
>>>
>>>  o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues (hardware
>>>    gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)
>>>
>>> Jan
>>>
>>> Thanks for the fast reply!
>>>
>>> I am using the following kernel parameters:
>>>
>>> kernel		/boot/vmlinuz-2.6.19-ipipe root=/dev/sda1 ro
> 8250.nr_uarts=0
>>> xeno_16550A.ioaddr=0x3f8 xeno_16550A.irq=4
>>>
>> OK, that leads to another suggestion: try going the modular path for
>> xeno_16550A first, it's the more common one. Above /should/ be no
>> problem /wrt the the RT driver, but kicking 8250 out of the game could
>> cause that PnP power issue I sketched.
>>
>>> I got these settings from setserial prior to disabling the
kernel-driver.
> To
>>> be honest i don't know how to 'check' /proc/xenomai/irq for progress. I
> took
>>> a look at the folder prior to and while running my modified
> cross-link-code
>>> but irq is an empty file in both cases. Is there some special
> trick/function
>>> to handle the files in the proc-folder?
>> You mean the file is existing but empty??? That would be fairly uncommon.
>>
>> (without any driver loaded)
>> # cat /proc/xenomai/irq
>> IRQ         CPU0
>> 217:           0
>> 226:           0         [virtual]
>>
>> The serial driver pops up here once the port is opened. The per-cpu irq
>> hit counter should then increase as interrupts come in.
>>
>>> To the last point.. so there is an updated version of the driver
>> available?
>>> I think i will try that one.. is it just a question of executing 'make'
>> and
>>> modprobing or are there more actions involved?
>> No, it's not that easy (more files, changed Makefiles and RTDM API).
>> First try the modular driver path, ie. keep 8250, switch off the Linux
>> port with setserial, and load the RT driver as a module. Then, if this
>> doesn't help, you could consider upgrading your Xenomai installation (at
>> least for a test) to SVN trunk.
>>
>> Jan
>> 
>> Ah, ok.. ehem... i tried to look at the file with gedit.. and it displays
>> nothing.. ;)
>> Now i get:
>> 
>> IRQ         CPU0
>>   4:           0         rtser0
>> 216:         521         [timer]
>> 226:         620         [virtual]
>> 
>> This is how it looks like after the program starts.. after that it
increases
>> just the [virtual] and the [timer] counter . Rtser0 stays at 0 all the
time
>> (although information is successfully written to the port, judging from
the
>> return value of rt_dev_write).
>> 
>> So i guess that is where the problem lies.. what can I do about that?
>
> Apply the other suggestion I made. You may try to talk to a dead device
> if 8250 is not loaded and takes over the PnP work.
>
> Jan

I already tried my luck with a modular driver.. does not work either..

Now i compiled a new 2.6.20-kernel with xenomai-trunk. I tried to modprobe
as usual:
modprobe xeno_16550A ioaddr=0x3f8 irq=4
but somehow the 'ioaddr'-parameter is not accepted by the module.. did
something change there?

Jonas

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver(rtser): NoRTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jonas Witt]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> Jonas Witt wrote:
>> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>>>> Hi everybody,
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a
> while
>>>>> now..
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> I have tried different programs like
>>>>> http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
>>>>> writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer).
>>> Opening
>>>>> a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also
>>> writing.
>>>>> The Problem stems from the call to:
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
>>>>> self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at
>>> least
>>>>> _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is
>>> working
>>>>> fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls
to
>>>>> rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really
be
>>>>> emphasized in the documentation..)
>>>>>
>>>> Some suggestions:
>>>>
>>>>  o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
>>>>    xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong
>>>>
>>>>  o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
>>>>    on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may
be
>>>>    wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
>>>>    broken.
>>>>
>>>>  o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues
(hardware
>>>>    gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)
>>>>
>>>> Jan
>>>>
>>>> Thanks for the fast reply!
>>>>
>>>> I am using the following kernel parameters:
>>>>
>>>> kernel		/boot/vmlinuz-2.6.19-ipipe root=/dev/sda1 ro
>> 8250.nr_uarts=0
>>>> xeno_16550A.ioaddr=0x3f8 xeno_16550A.irq=4
>>>>
>>> OK, that leads to another suggestion: try going the modular path for
>>> xeno_16550A first, it's the more common one. Above /should/ be no
>>> problem /wrt the the RT driver, but kicking 8250 out of the game could
>>> cause that PnP power issue I sketched.
>>>
>>>> I got these settings from setserial prior to disabling the
> kernel-driver.
>> To
>>>> be honest i don't know how to 'check' /proc/xenomai/irq for progress. I
>> took
>>>> a look at the folder prior to and while running my modified
>> cross-link-code
>>>> but irq is an empty file in both cases. Is there some special
>> trick/function
>>>> to handle the files in the proc-folder?
>>> You mean the file is existing but empty??? That would be fairly
uncommon.
>>>
>>> (without any driver loaded)
>>> # cat /proc/xenomai/irq
>>> IRQ         CPU0
>>> 217:           0
>>> 226:           0         [virtual]
>>>
>>> The serial driver pops up here once the port is opened. The per-cpu irq
>>> hit counter should then increase as interrupts come in.
>>>
>>>> To the last point.. so there is an updated version of the driver
>>> available?
>>>> I think i will try that one.. is it just a question of executing 'make'
>>> and
>>>> modprobing or are there more actions involved?
>>> No, it's not that easy (more files, changed Makefiles and RTDM API).
>>> First try the modular driver path, ie. keep 8250, switch off the Linux
>>> port with setserial, and load the RT driver as a module. Then, if this
>>> doesn't help, you could consider upgrading your Xenomai installation (at
>>> least for a test) to SVN trunk.
>>>
>>> Jan
>>>
>>> Ah, ok.. ehem... i tried to look at the file with gedit.. and it
displays
>>> nothing.. ;)
>>> Now i get:
>>>
>>> IRQ         CPU0
>>>   4:           0         rtser0
>>> 216:         521         [timer]
>>> 226:         620         [virtual]
>>>
>>> This is how it looks like after the program starts.. after that it
> increases
>>> just the [virtual] and the [timer] counter . Rtser0 stays at 0 all the
> time
>>> (although information is successfully written to the port, judging from
> the
>>> return value of rt_dev_write).
>>>
>>> So i guess that is where the problem lies.. what can I do about that?
>> Apply the other suggestion I made. You may try to talk to a dead device
>> if 8250 is not loaded and takes over the PnP work.
>>
>> Jan
>> 
>> I already tried my luck with a modular driver.. does not work either..
>> 
>
> :-/
>
>> Now i compiled a new 2.6.20-kernel with xenomai-trunk. I tried to
modprobe
>> as usual:
>> modprobe xeno_16550A ioaddr=0x3f8 irq=4
>> but somehow the 'ioaddr'-parameter is not accepted by the module.. did
>> something change there?
>
> Yep, it has been refactored to "io=" (like other Xenomai drivers).
> 
> Jan

Sorry.. i drew a wrong conclusion.. actually changing to a modular serial
driver and deactivating the kernel-driver with setserial does change the
situation in /proc/xenomai/irq: now the rtser0 entry is counted upwards,
too. Anyway this does not change the situation with my modified cross-link
program (that's where i drew the wrong conclusion, since i tested with a
modular serial driver before).

Anyway.. i am going to try the latest driver-version now. With the new
infos, is there another thing i can check?

Jonas

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver(rtser):NoRTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jonas Witt]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> Jonas Witt wrote:
>> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>>>> Hi everybody,
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a
> while
>>>>> now..
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> I have tried different programs like
>>>>> http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
>>>>> writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer).
>>> Opening
>>>>> a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also
>>> writing.
>>>>> The Problem stems from the call to:
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
>>>>> self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at
>>> least
>>>>> _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is
>>> working
>>>>> fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls
to
>>>>> rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really
be
>>>>> emphasized in the documentation..)
>>>>>
>>>> Some suggestions:
>>>>
>>>>  o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
>>>>    xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong
>>>>
>>>>  o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
>>>>    on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may
be
>>>>    wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
>>>>    broken.
>>>>
>>>>  o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues
(hardware
>>>>    gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)
>>>>
>>>> Jan
>>>>
>>>> Thanks for the fast reply!
>>>>
>>>> I am using the following kernel parameters:
>>>>
>>>> kernel		/boot/vmlinuz-2.6.19-ipipe root=/dev/sda1 ro
>> 8250.nr_uarts=0
>>>> xeno_16550A.ioaddr=0x3f8 xeno_16550A.irq=4
>>>>
>>> OK, that leads to another suggestion: try going the modular path for
>>> xeno_16550A first, it's the more common one. Above /should/ be no
>>> problem /wrt the the RT driver, but kicking 8250 out of the game could
>>> cause that PnP power issue I sketched.
>>>
>>>> I got these settings from setserial prior to disabling the
> kernel-driver.
>> To
>>>> be honest i don't know how to 'check' /proc/xenomai/irq for progress. I
>> took
>>>> a look at the folder prior to and while running my modified
>> cross-link-code
>>>> but irq is an empty file in both cases. Is there some special
>> trick/function
>>>> to handle the files in the proc-folder?
>>> You mean the file is existing but empty??? That would be fairly
uncommon.
>>>
>>> (without any driver loaded)
>>> # cat /proc/xenomai/irq
>>> IRQ         CPU0
>>> 217:           0
>>> 226:           0         [virtual]
>>>
>>> The serial driver pops up here once the port is opened. The per-cpu irq
>>> hit counter should then increase as interrupts come in.
>>>
>>>> To the last point.. so there is an updated version of the driver
>>> available?
>>>> I think i will try that one.. is it just a question of executing 'make'
>>> and
>>>> modprobing or are there more actions involved?
>>> No, it's not that easy (more files, changed Makefiles and RTDM API).
>>> First try the modular driver path, ie. keep 8250, switch off the Linux
>>> port with setserial, and load the RT driver as a module. Then, if this
>>> doesn't help, you could consider upgrading your Xenomai installation (at
>>> least for a test) to SVN trunk.
>>>
>>> Jan
>>>
>>> Ah, ok.. ehem... i tried to look at the file with gedit.. and it
displays
>>> nothing.. ;)
>>> Now i get:
>>>
>>> IRQ         CPU0
>>>   4:           0         rtser0
>>> 216:         521         [timer]
>>> 226:         620         [virtual]
>>>
>>> This is how it looks like after the program starts.. after that it
> increases
>>> just the [virtual] and the [timer] counter . Rtser0 stays at 0 all the
> time
>>> (although information is successfully written to the port, judging from
> the
>>> return value of rt_dev_write).
>>>
>>> So i guess that is where the problem lies.. what can I do about that?
>> Apply the other suggestion I made. You may try to talk to a dead device
>> if 8250 is not loaded and takes over the PnP work.
>>
>> Jan
>> 
>> I already tried my luck with a modular driver.. does not work either..
>> 
>
> :-/
>
>> Now i compiled a new 2.6.20-kernel with xenomai-trunk. I tried to
modprobe
>> as usual:
>> modprobe xeno_16550A ioaddr=0x3f8 irq=4
>> but somehow the 'ioaddr'-parameter is not accepted by the module.. did
>> something change there?
>
> Yep, it has been refactored to "io=" (like other Xenomai drivers).
> 
> Jan

Sorry.. i drew a wrong conclusion.. actually changing to a modular serial
driver and deactivating the kernel-driver with setserial does change the
situation in /proc/xenomai/irq: now the rtser0 entry is counted upwards,
too. Anyway this does not change the situation with my modified cross-link
program (that's where i drew the wrong conclusion, since i tested with a
modular serial driver before).

Anyway.. i am going to try the latest driver-version now. With the new
infos, is there another thing i can check?

Jonas

Update:
With the Xenomai-trunk version it's the exact same picture. By the way.. i
don't know if this is of importance, but during the systemstart i get this
message:
MP-BIOS bug: 8254 timer not connected to IO-APIC

Jonas
_______________________________________________
Xenomai-help mailing list
Xenomai-help@domain.hid
https://mail.gna.org/listinfo/xenomai-help

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver(rtser): No RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jan Kiszka]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 4858 bytes --]

Jonas Witt wrote:
> Jonas Witt wrote:
>> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>> Jonas Witt wrote:
>>>>> Hi everybody,
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> i am having a problem with the serial port driver in xenomai for a
> while
>>>>> now..
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> I have tried different programs like
>>>>> http://www.captain.at/xenomai-serial-port-example.php
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> I have also changed the code of cross-link.c to use the same port for
>>>>> writing and reading (as i only have one serial port in my computer).
>>> Opening
>>>>> a port and writing the configuration seems to work form e.. also
>>> writing.
>>>>> The Problem stems from the call to:
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> rt_dev_ioctl(read_fd, RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT, &rx_event);
>>>>>
>>>>>  
>>>>>
>>>>> which keeps waiting forever and never receives an interrupt. I tried a
>>>>> self-made loopback-adapter and a sensor with a serial interface (so at
>>> least
>>>>> _something_ should come back). Nothing worked. The serial port is
>>> working
>>>>> fine with the linux-driver, though. I already figured that the calls to
>>>>> rt_dev_write do not work from non-xenomai-tasks (which should really be
>>>>> emphasized in the documentation..)
>>>>>
>>>> Some suggestions:
>>>>
>>>>  o check the hardware configuration (ie. the module parameters of
>>>>    xeno_16550A) twice, you can easily get them wrong
>>>>
>>>>  o check /proc/xenomai/irq for any progress on transmission as well as
>>>>    on reception. If there is nothing happen on tx, the IRQ number may be
>>>>    wrong, if there is nothing on rx, your port configuration might be
>>>>    broken.
>>>>
>>>>  o try the driver from trunk, it can handle PnP-related issues (hardware
>>>>    gets powered off when Linux driver is removed)
>>>>
>>>> Jan
>>>>
>>>> Thanks for the fast reply!
>>>>
>>>> I am using the following kernel parameters:
>>>>
>>>> kernel		/boot/vmlinuz-2.6.19-ipipe root=/dev/sda1 ro
>> 8250.nr_uarts=0
>>>> xeno_16550A.ioaddr=0x3f8 xeno_16550A.irq=4
>>>>
>>> OK, that leads to another suggestion: try going the modular path for
>>> xeno_16550A first, it's the more common one. Above /should/ be no
>>> problem /wrt the the RT driver, but kicking 8250 out of the game could
>>> cause that PnP power issue I sketched.
>>>
>>>> I got these settings from setserial prior to disabling the
> kernel-driver.
>> To
>>>> be honest i don't know how to 'check' /proc/xenomai/irq for progress. I
>> took
>>>> a look at the folder prior to and while running my modified
>> cross-link-code
>>>> but irq is an empty file in both cases. Is there some special
>> trick/function
>>>> to handle the files in the proc-folder?
>>> You mean the file is existing but empty??? That would be fairly uncommon.
>>>
>>> (without any driver loaded)
>>> # cat /proc/xenomai/irq
>>> IRQ         CPU0
>>> 217:           0
>>> 226:           0         [virtual]
>>>
>>> The serial driver pops up here once the port is opened. The per-cpu irq
>>> hit counter should then increase as interrupts come in.
>>>
>>>> To the last point.. so there is an updated version of the driver
>>> available?
>>>> I think i will try that one.. is it just a question of executing 'make'
>>> and
>>>> modprobing or are there more actions involved?
>>> No, it's not that easy (more files, changed Makefiles and RTDM API).
>>> First try the modular driver path, ie. keep 8250, switch off the Linux
>>> port with setserial, and load the RT driver as a module. Then, if this
>>> doesn't help, you could consider upgrading your Xenomai installation (at
>>> least for a test) to SVN trunk.
>>>
>>> Jan
>>>
>>> Ah, ok.. ehem... i tried to look at the file with gedit.. and it displays
>>> nothing.. ;)
>>> Now i get:
>>>
>>> IRQ         CPU0
>>>   4:           0         rtser0
>>> 216:         521         [timer]
>>> 226:         620         [virtual]
>>>
>>> This is how it looks like after the program starts.. after that it
> increases
>>> just the [virtual] and the [timer] counter . Rtser0 stays at 0 all the
> time
>>> (although information is successfully written to the port, judging from
> the
>>> return value of rt_dev_write).
>>>
>>> So i guess that is where the problem lies.. what can I do about that?
>> Apply the other suggestion I made. You may try to talk to a dead device
>> if 8250 is not loaded and takes over the PnP work.
>>
>> Jan
> 
> I already tried my luck with a modular driver.. does not work either..
> 

:-/

> Now i compiled a new 2.6.20-kernel with xenomai-trunk. I tried to modprobe
> as usual:
> modprobe xeno_16550A ioaddr=0x3f8 irq=4
> but somehow the 'ioaddr'-parameter is not accepted by the module.. did
> something change there?

Yep, it has been refactored to "io=" (like other Xenomai drivers).

Jan


[-- Attachment #2: OpenPGP digital signature --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 249 bytes --]

[Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): No RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jonas]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 426 bytes --]

No other ideas for me to try out? So the driver seems to get interrupts..
where could it possibly fail?

 

Another question concerning xenomai's booting process.. are any files other
than from the /boot, /lib/modules and /usr/xenomai needed for the boot
process (because on another platform I am having some issues with booting
when the files from the build-folder are not available while booting).

 

Best regards,

Jonas


[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 2237 bytes --]

Re: [Xenomai-help] Serial Port Driver (rtser): No RTSER_RTIOC_WAIT_EVENT

[Jan Kiszka]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 840 bytes --]

Jonas@domain.hid wrote:
> No other ideas for me to try out? So the driver seems to get interrupts=
=2E.
> where could it possibly fail?
>=20

Interrupts on what? Only transmission or also reception? Try the
_original_ crosslink example with a nullmodem cable and two PCs (as you
only have one port on one of the boxes).

>=20
> Another question concerning xenomai's booting process.. are any files o=
ther
> than from the /boot, /lib/modules and /usr/xenomai needed for the boot
> process (because on another platform I am having some issues with booti=
ng
> when the files from the build-folder are not available while booting).
>=20

Please describe the issue more precisely. In any case, Xenomai's
userland (/usr/xenomai here) is _not_ required to get the system
running, only when you want to start the first Xenomai application.

Jan


[-- Attachment #2: OpenPGP digital signature --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 250 bytes --]