qemu/kvm: support for pci passthrough

qemu/kvm: support for pci passthrough

[Nicolas Daneau]

Hi,

I saw there was an active discussion about pci passthrough support in
KVM. I'm not a Dev, only a sys admin that need this support. As i saw
on the KVM home page that this feature is plan for 2H2008 in the
roadmap, I wondered if you already have a more precise time frame for
this release? Xen already have this feature but for the rest i prfer
KVM. As this is a key point for the final decsion (we have a Digium
TDM11B FXO/FXS pci card for an Asterisk VM), i'm waiting for an update
about this feature.

Thanks for your answer

-- 
Nicolas Daneau
   Rue Maurice Bertrand 543
   5300 Landenne
   Belgium
   0486/69.01.65

Re: qemu/kvm: support for pci passthrough

[Dor Laor]

On Thu, 2008-05-08 at 12:03 +0200, Nicolas Daneau wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> I saw there was an active discussion about pci passthrough support in
> KVM. I'm not a Dev, only a sys admin that need this support. As i saw
> on the KVM home page that this feature is plan for 2H2008 in the
> roadmap, I wondered if you already have a more precise time frame for
> this release? Xen already have this feature but for the rest i prfer
> KVM. As this is a key point for the final decsion (we have a Digium
> TDM11B FXO/FXS pci card for an Asterisk VM), i'm waiting for an update
> about this feature.
> 

This is feature is indeed work in progress. We have floating patches for
several solutions:
1. Using Intel's VT-d - hw iommu support.
   Patches were sent, needs some more scrubbing. The good thing is that 
   it can live withing the kvm module and does not have to wait for 
   kernel inclusion like the two below.
2. PV dma - good only for Linux guests. Some locking issues needs to be 
   solved + get into mainline kernel (>=2.6.27)
3. 1-1 mapping of the guest-host addresses. 
   Will work for any guest, no need for special hw, good only for 
   single guest and not 100% secure.
   Needs a little more attention, worked in the past privately.

Bottom line, soon you'll have more than one option for pci pass through
using kvm. There is no assurance we'll make it exactly in Q2.
You can help by applying patches and sending results.
Cheers,
Dor

> Thanks for your answer
> 

Re: qemu/kvm: support for pci passthrough

[Anthony Liguori]

Dor Laor wrote:
> On Thu, 2008-05-08 at 12:03 +0200, Nicolas Daneau wrote:
>> Hi,
>>
>> I saw there was an active discussion about pci passthrough support in
>> KVM. I'm not a Dev, only a sys admin that need this support. As i saw
>> on the KVM home page that this feature is plan for 2H2008 in the
>> roadmap, I wondered if you already have a more precise time frame for
>> this release? Xen already have this feature but for the rest i prfer
>> KVM. As this is a key point for the final decsion (we have a Digium
>> TDM11B FXO/FXS pci card for an Asterisk VM), i'm waiting for an update
>> about this feature.
>>
> 
> This is feature is indeed work in progress. We have floating patches for
> several solutions:
> 1. Using Intel's VT-d - hw iommu support.
>    Patches were sent, needs some more scrubbing. The good thing is that 
>    it can live withing the kvm module and does not have to wait for 
>    kernel inclusion like the two below.

Nope, it uses the existing Linux VT-d support and requires patches to 
the existing code.  It can't live entirely within the external module.

Regards,

Anthony Liguori


> 2. PV dma - good only for Linux guests. Some locking issues needs to be 
>    solved + get into mainline kernel (>=2.6.27)
> 3. 1-1 mapping of the guest-host addresses. 
>    Will work for any guest, no need for special hw, good only for 
>    single guest and not 100% secure.
>    Needs a little more attention, worked in the past privately.
> 
> Bottom line, soon you'll have more than one option for pci pass through
> using kvm. There is no assurance we'll make it exactly in Q2.
> You can help by applying patches and sending results.
> Cheers,
> Dor
> 
>> Thanks for your answer
>>


-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by the 2008 JavaOne(SM) Conference 
Don't miss this year's exciting event. There's still time to save $100. 
Use priority code J8TL2D2. 
http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;198757673;13503038;p?http://java.sun.com/javaone