Re: [PATCH iwl-next v4 0/9] igc: Add support for Frame Preemption feature in IGC

["Abdul Rahim, Faizal" <faizal.abdul.rahim@linux.intel.com>]

On 14/2/2025 12:20 pm, Abdul Rahim, Faizal wrote:
> 
> 
> On 14/2/2025 3:12 am, Kurt Kanzenbach wrote:
>> On Thu Feb 13 2025, Vladimir Oltean wrote:
>>> So, confusingly to me, it seems like one operating mode is fundamentally
>>> different from the other, and something will have to change if both will
>>> be made to behave the same. What will change? You say mqprio will behave
>>> like taprio, but I think if anything, mqprio is the one which does the
>>> right thing, in igc_tsn_tx_arb(), and taprio seems to use the default Tx
>>> arbitration scheme?
>>
>> Correct. taprio is using the default scheme. mqprio configures it to
>> what ever the user provided (in igc_tsn_tx_arb()).
>>
>>> I don't think I'm on the same page as you guys, because to me, it is
>>> just odd that the P traffic classes would be the first ones with
>>> mqprio, but the last ones with taprio.
>>
>> I think we are on the same page here. At the end both have to behave the
>> same. Either by using igc_tsn_tx_arb() for taprio too or only using the
>> default scheme for both (and thereby keeping broken_mqprio). Whatever
>> Faizal implements I'll match the behavior with mqprio.
>>
> 
> Hi Kurt & Vladimir,
> 
> After reading Vladimir's reply on tc, hw queue, and socket priority mapping 
> for both taprio and mqprio, I agree they should follow the same priority 
> scheme for consistency—both in code and command usage (i.e., taprio, 
> mqprio, and fpe in both configurations). Since igc_tsn_tx_arb() ensures a 
> standard mapping of tc, socket priority, and hardware queue priority, I'll 
> enable taprio to use igc_tsn_tx_arb() in a separate patch submission.
> 
> I'll split the changes based on Vladimir's suggestion.
> 
> First part - ethtool-mm related:
> igc: Add support to get frame preemption statistics via ethtool
> igc: Add support to get MAC Merge data via ethtool
> igc: Add support to set tx-min-frag-size
> igc: Add support for frame preemption verification
> igc: Set the RX packet buffer size for TSN mode
> igc: Optimize TX packet buffer utilization
> igc: Rename xdp_get_tx_ring() for non-XDP usage
> net: ethtool: mm: Extract stmmac verification logic into a common library
> 
> Second part:
> igc: Add support for preemptible traffic class in taprio and mqprio
> igc: Use igc_tsn_tx_arb() for taprio queue priority scheme
> igc: Kurt's patch on mqprio to use normal TSN Tx mode
> 
> Kurt can keep igc_tsn_tx_arb() for his mqprio patch, so preemptible tc 
> should work the same for both taprio and mqprio.
> 
> I'm suggesting to include Kurt's patch in the second part since there's 
> some dependency and potential code conflict, even though it mixes different 
> functional changes in the same series.

I forgot that the second part patch:
igc: Add support for preemptible traffic class in taprio and mqprio

depends on the first part ethtool-mm, which would delay Kurt's patch.

So Kurt, if you'd prefer to submit yours first, that's okay too.