problems with large group descriptors and 64bit

problems with large group descriptors and 64bit

[Andreas Dilger]

I was just looking through the 64-bit patches that have landed on master, and I see some obvious bugs with the handling of large group descriptors.  In particular, there are some places that still assume they know the group descriptor size, even in the "opaque" routines added by Eric in commit efe0b401465a3ee836180614b5b435acbb84fc27.

lib/ext2fs/open.c assumes ext2_group_desc in a couple of places, instead of calling ext2fs_group_desc() to get the right offset:
#ifdef WORDS_BIGENDIAN  
                gdp = (struct ext2_group_desc *) dest;
                for (j=0; j < groups_per_block*first_meta_bg; j++)
                        ext2fs_swap_group_desc2(fs, gdp++);
#endif


lib/ext2fs/blknum.c assumes 64BIT means ext4_group_desc, not s_desc_size:
struct ext2_group_desc *ext2fs_group_desc(ext2_filsys fs,
                                          struct opaque_ext2_group_desc *gdp,
                                          dgrp_t group)
{               
        if (fs->super->s_desc_size >= EXT2_MIN_DESC_SIZE_64BIT)
                return (struct ext2_group_desc *)
                        ((struct ext4_group_desc *) gdp + group);
        else
                return (struct ext2_group_desc *) gdp + group;
}




Cheers, Andreas
--
Andreas Dilger
Lustre Technical Lead
Oracle Corporation Canada Inc.

Re: problems with large group descriptors and 64bit

[Valerie Aurora]

On Tue, Jun 22, 2010 at 05:24:34PM -0600, Andreas Dilger wrote:
> I was just looking through the 64-bit patches that have landed on master, and I see some obvious bugs with the handling of large group descriptors.  In particular, there are some places that still assume they know the group descriptor size, even in the "opaque" routines added by Eric in commit efe0b401465a3ee836180614b5b435acbb84fc27.
> 
> lib/ext2fs/open.c assumes ext2_group_desc in a couple of places, instead of calling ext2fs_group_desc() to get the right offset:
> #ifdef WORDS_BIGENDIAN  
>                 gdp = (struct ext2_group_desc *) dest;
>                 for (j=0; j < groups_per_block*first_meta_bg; j++)
>                         ext2fs_swap_group_desc2(fs, gdp++);
> #endif

Yeah, Eric and I pointed this one out when they went in but didn't
hear back.  I never compiled with big-endian, much less tested it.  I
suspect getting 64-bit working on big-endian will require fixing a
number of other bugs.

> lib/ext2fs/blknum.c assumes 64BIT means ext4_group_desc, not s_desc_size:
> struct ext2_group_desc *ext2fs_group_desc(ext2_filsys fs,
>                                           struct opaque_ext2_group_desc *gdp,
>                                           dgrp_t group)
> {               
>         if (fs->super->s_desc_size >= EXT2_MIN_DESC_SIZE_64BIT)
>                 return (struct ext2_group_desc *)
>                         ((struct ext4_group_desc *) gdp + group);
>         else
>                 return (struct ext2_group_desc *) gdp + group;
> }

I'm not sure I understand.  Are there more than two possible sizes for
group descriptors?  Or is the existing code correct but you'd like to
use s_desc_size directly for simplicity?  Or something else?

Thanks,

-VAL

Re: problems with large group descriptors and 64bit

[Andreas Dilger]

On 2010-06-24, at 11:41 AM, Valerie Aurora <vaurora@redhat.com> wrote:

> On Tue, Jun 22, 2010 at 05:24:34PM -0600, Andreas Dilger wrote:
> 
>> lib/ext2fs/blknum.c assumes 64BIT means ext4_group_desc, not s_desc_size:
>> struct ext2_group_desc *ext2fs_group_desc(ext2_filsys fs,
>>                                          struct opaque_ext2_group_desc *gdp,
>>                                          dgrp_t group)
>> {               
>>        if (fs->super->s_desc_size >= EXT2_MIN_DESC_SIZE_64BIT)
>>                return (struct ext2_group_desc *)
>>                        ((struct ext4_group_desc *) gdp + group);
>>        else
>>                return (struct ext2_group_desc *) gdp + group;
>> }
> 
> I'm not sure I understand.  Are there more than two possible sizes for
> group descriptors?  Or is the existing code correct but you'd like to
> use s_desc_size directly for simplicity?

When the 64BIT flag is set the size kid the group descriptor is given by s_group_desc, which is currently the same as struct ext4_group_desc, but it might be larger in the future.