Re: Question: errors=continue behaviour for failed external journal device

[Vlad Dobrotescu <vlad@dobrotescu.ca>]

On 26/07/2014 20:07, Theodore Ts'o wrote:
> On Sat, Jul 26, 2014 at 11:07:59PM +0000, Vlad Dobrotescu wrote:
>> If this isn't the proper place for this question, please point me in
>> the right direction.
>>
>> I couldn't find any description on Ext4's behaviour when mounted
>> with errors=continue and external journal if the journal block device
>> is unavailable at mount time (or becomes unavailable at some point).
>>
>> I would be using CentOS 7 (kernel 3.10.0-123.4.4.el7 x86_64) and
>> (probably) full data journaling on a SSD. Can someone help?
> So there are two different questions.
>
> If you use errors=continue, there is the chance that the file system
> inconsistencies that discovered could cause further file system
> damage, which might lead to the loss or corruption of data files
> written earlier.  So it's not really recommended for most purposes,
> unless you have some scheme where you are monitoring dmesgs and having
> some strategy to deal with detected file system errors, or when the
> system absolutely, positively must continue running, and this is more
> important than potential data loss.
>
> If the journal block device is not present then the file system can't
> be mounted, and if the system was uncleanly shut down you won't be
> able to recover from the unclean shutdown by replaying the journal.
>
> If the journal block device is *gone*, it is possible to remove the
> external journal block device, and then force a file system repair,
> but if this happens after an unclean shutdown, you may very well lose
> data.
>
> Cheers,
>
> 						- Ted

Sorry if this is a duplicate, but the "Followup" didn't seem to work for me

Thanks for the quick and detailed answer. If I understand it correctly,
the errors= option has nothing to do with journaling, but only with FS
consistency issues (which can be caused by a vanished journal, but also
by other events), while the mounting itself fails in the absence of the
device specified for external journaling, with no fall-back alternative.
Right?

Vlad