[linux-lvm] unable to create permanent physical volume on /dev/hdc

[linux-lvm] unable to create permanent physical volume on /dev/hdc

[David Claessens]

Hi,

I have a machine with 4 disks assigned to LVM. I recently re-installed 
this machine and upgraded it to a custom compiled 2.6 kernel (2.6.7 to 
be specific) but now I'm having troubles recreating my LVM. I have 
assigned /dev/hda6, /dev/hdb, /dev/hdc en /dev/hdd to LVM with the 
'pvcreate' command without any error (I did run the dd command from the 
howto first). When I run 'pvs' I see my 4 physical volumes, however when 
I run 'pvscan' it only lists 3 of the 4 physical volumes. /dev/hdc is 
missing from the list. When I run 'pvs' again it now also only shows 3 
of the 4 physical volumes. However if I run 'pvs /dev/hdc' it shows me 
my 4 physical volumes, 'pvscan' always shows only 3. Also after running 
'pvscan', I can run 'pvcreate' again on /dev/hdc without any error and 
running 'pvs' without any arguments will show 4 volumes.

I have no problems creating a primary partition spanning the disk. 
However running 'pvcreate /dev/hdc1' also works without an error but it 
still won't show up in a pvscan. What could be the problem that hdc 
won't be a physical volume or what commands could/should I run to more 
accurately debug/fix the problem ??

The system is running on Debian 3.0 upgraded to testing and I have a 
duplicate with the same setup that is running without any problem. Also 
LVM2 is working perfectly using the 3 working physical volumes.

Re: [linux-lvm] unable to create permanent physical volume on /dev/hdc

[Patrick Caulfield]

On Tue, Jul 20, 2004 at 01:13:54PM +0200, David Claessens wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> I have a machine with 4 disks assigned to LVM. I recently re-installed 
> this machine and upgraded it to a custom compiled 2.6 kernel (2.6.7 to 
> be specific) but now I'm having troubles recreating my LVM. I have 
> assigned /dev/hda6, /dev/hdb, /dev/hdc en /dev/hdd to LVM with the 
> 'pvcreate' command without any error (I did run the dd command from the 
> howto first). When I run 'pvs' I see my 4 physical volumes, however when 
> I run 'pvscan' it only lists 3 of the 4 physical volumes. /dev/hdc is 
> missing from the list. When I run 'pvs' again it now also only shows 3 
> of the 4 physical volumes. However if I run 'pvs /dev/hdc' it shows me 
> my 4 physical volumes, 'pvscan' always shows only 3. Also after running 
> 'pvscan', I can run 'pvcreate' again on /dev/hdc without any error and 
> running 'pvs' without any arguments will show 4 volumes.
> 
> I have no problems creating a primary partition spanning the disk. 
> However running 'pvcreate /dev/hdc1' also works without an error but it 
> still won't show up in a pvscan. What could be the problem that hdc 
> won't be a physical volume or what commands could/should I run to more 
> accurately debug/fix the problem ??
> 
> The system is running on Debian 3.0 upgraded to testing and I have a 
> duplicate with the same setup that is running without any problem. Also 
> LVM2 is working perfectly using the 3 working physical volumes.

Check the config file (/etc/lvm/lvm.conf) for filters. By default /dev/cdrom is
filtered out on Debian systems and this often gets mapped to /dev/hdc. Which
would cause those symptoms.

Simply comment out the active "filter = " line and run vgscan.

-- 

patrick

Re: [linux-lvm] unable to create permanent physical volume on /dev/hdc

[David Claessens]

Thanks, this is probably the case. I disconnected hdc and hdd and hooked 
up a dvd-rom to do the re-install which was /dev/hdc during the 
re-install. I will check later today when I have access to the machine.

Patrick Caulfield wrote:
> 
> 
> Check the config file (/etc/lvm/lvm.conf) for filters. By default /dev/cdrom is
> filtered out on Debian systems and this often gets mapped to /dev/hdc. Which
> would cause those symptoms.
> 
> Simply comment out the active "filter = " line and run vgscan.
> 

-- 
There is no doubt about precisely when folks began racing each other in 
automobiles. It was the day they built the second automobile. -- Richard 
Petty