[parisc-linux] 2.5 status update 2003-01-14

[parisc-linux] 2.5 status update 2003-01-14

[Matthew Wilcox]

A new year, a new kernel.  Er, lots of new kernels.  So much stuff has been
going on, I hope I haven't left too much out (note: do these more often).

 - Lamont prompted me to fix dino_inb/inw/outb/outw, and the airo driver.
 - Lamont wrote faster ip_csum routines.
 - Helge went completely nuts on drivers/video ;-)
 - James did some of the merges while I was away over xmas, and did a lot
   of work converting us over to the generic device model.
 - James & Randolph also finally tracked down a big stability problem;
   needed to check signals more often.
 - Lamont improved the unaligned handler.
 - We have a new framebuffer penguin ;-)  Thanks, Thibaut!
 - Randolph wrote oprofile support for parisc.
 - I found & fixed the cause of init failing to start on my 712 -- the
   kernel was trying to make sure there was at least 80MB ram available
   for each process.
 - I integrated Stephen Rothwell's generic compat changes & Sam Ravnborg's
   Makefile changes.

We did a large merge into Linus' tree yesterday, and he put out 2.5.58
today, leaving our diff standing around:

-rw-r--r--    1 willy    willy      376145 Jan 14 08:38 parisc-2.5.diff

I think that's the smallest it's ever been.

The largest chunks of that are:

-rw-r--r--    1 willy    willy      166953 Jan 12 07:54 parisc-hil.diff
-rw-r--r--    1 willy    willy      151345 Jan 12 07:47 parisc-video.diff

I'm not worried about drivers/video; Helge's doing a great job staying
synchronised with James Simmons' fb tree and that artificially inflates
that diff.

I am a little worried about the HIL keyboard/mouse/etc.  If someone could
step up to take care of making them work in 2.5 and generally look after
them, that'd be great.


Here's the current todo list:

Status:
-------
 - Merged to 2.5.58
 - 2.5.57 booted on A500.  712 has serial problems.
 - 2.5.56 booted on A500, 712
 - Don't know what other patches need to be brought forward from 2.4
 - SMP compiles, but doesn't work yet
 - No preemptible support


Todo:
-----
 - review makefiles for safe parallel builds
 - review diff vs 2.4 for additional changes
 - Serial code not working for c3000 (helge)
 - the fix for do_fork needs checking
 - Some options still need Kconfig help entries
 - drivers/char/keyboard.c:987:2: warning: #warning "Cannot generate rawmode
        keyboard for your architecture yet."
 - our PDC early debug console hacks need to be cleaned up somehow
 - drivers/pci/setup-bus.c has a hppa-specific #ifdef right now to
   prevent pci reinit from hpmc'ing the machine. this probably needs to
   go upstream
 - ad1889 driver - stress, debug, ALSA and commit to 2.5 (ggg, tausq, tbone)
 - ns87415 dma doesn't work reliably on suckyio-systems
 - CPU hotplug support (maybe not needed, V-Class doesn't support that feature)
 - flush_tlb_kernel_range is horribly inefficient
 - flush_icache_user_range could flush just that range rather than the
   entire page.
 - (ab)use kmap/kunmap on 64-bit to eliminate flush_dcache calls.
 - cp_new_stat32 for sys_parisc32.c is inefficient; maybe it's better
   to fill in a tmp stat32 and just do copy_to_user in one go at the end?
 - syscall signal return path needs work
 - task_struct/thread_info split -- task_struct should not be visible in
   entry.S, we need to move some items into thread_info -- this includes
   pt_regs and maybe some of the flags (ptrace, etc)
 - Use zone_highmem for the 256MB of RAM at 64GB on Astro-based machines.
   (NB, what does Stretch do?)
 - investigate not putting in extable entries for put_kernel_asm; will
   probably reduce kernel size
 - call to pdc_suspend_usb() in inventory.c crashes c3k with kernel 2.5
 - fix harmony buffer-overflows
 - fix HIL problem: ksoftirqd eats 100% cpu (kernel 2.4; kernel 2.5?)
 - write floppy driver for lasi
 - write floppy driver for suckyio
 - CONFIG_INTERMEZZO_FS   doesn't build (or link) (missing intermezzo includes, arch-indep)
 - CONFIG_REISERFS_FS builds (and links), works built-in
 - CONFIG_XFS_FS builds (and links), infinite loop when mounting volume.
 - spifi driver (rbrad)
 - write optimized versions of lcopy_{to,from}_user. Can we port the
   hpux versions?
 - changes in arch/parisc/kernel/signal.c regarding HACK needs testing
 - signal.c #if CACHE_FLUSHING_IS_NOT_BROKEN needs to be solved
 - proc files are b0rken (interrupts), possible irqi funcs related pb.
 - the irq needs to go from doubly-indexed to singly-indexed scheme, or else fs/proc/proc_misc.c needs changes.
 - kernel module loader support
 - IRQ cpu-affinity support
 - NPTL kernel support (CLONE_*TID flags need to be correctly handled by
   sys_clone() and friends)

 Started and in progress:
 ------------------------
 - port sym53c8xx hppa changes forward (helge)
 - push STI changes upstream (helge)
 - Look at Config.help too. (tbone, HIL -> helge?)
 - send tulip changes to jgarzik (grant)
 - switching Harmony to ALSA (laurent)
 - remove all references to sti(), cli(), save_flags() and restore_flags() (willy, tbone, ...)
 - send pci-serial patches to rmk (tausq)
 - port hil_kbd.c to new input layer
 - port hil_ptr.c to new input layer
 - oprofile support (tausq)


 Done:
 -----
 - stifb & sticon compiles and works (helge)
 - port ns87415 hppa changes forward (grant)
 - implemented synchronize_irq(). (grant)
 - port hp_keyb.c to input layer (laurent, tbone)


 CONFIG options without help:
 -----------------------------
 _USB_OHCI_HCD (add parisc info?)
 _HP_SDC_RTC
 _HIL_MLC
 _HIL_KBD (to improve)
 _HIL_PTR (to improve)

-- 
"It's not Hollywood.  War is real, war is primarily not about defeat or
victory, it is about death.  I've seen thousands and thousands of dead bodies.
Do you think I want to have an academic debate on this subject?" -- Robert Fisk

Re: [parisc-linux] 2.5 status update 2003-01-14

[Grant Grundler]

On Tue, Jan 14, 2003 at 03:54:09PM +0000, Matthew Wilcox wrote:
>  - drivers/pci/setup-bus.c has a hppa-specific #ifdef right now to
>    prevent pci reinit from hpmc'ing the machine. this probably needs to
>    go upstream

This code has changed alot. I'll look at it this week to see if
we still need this and if so, how to get rid of it.

>  - ad1889 driver - stress, debug, ALSA and commit to 2.5 (ggg, tausq, tbone)

What we have now only groks .wav files (eg cat foo.wav > /dev/audio).
We need better docs for this chip.
The ad1889.pdf data sheet is only an abbreviated guide to the chip.
It's not good enough for writing a driver from scratch.

>  - CPU hotplug support (maybe not needed, V-Class doesn't support that feature)

While we may not be able to physically remove the CPU, it would be
useful to take CPUs "offline" when they start misbehaving.

>  - fix harmony buffer-overflows

Laurent rewrote harmony to be Alsa compliant and it seems to be working.
I just have to learn how to setup/use alsa properly.

>  - the irq needs to go from doubly-indexed to singly-indexed scheme, or else fs/proc/proc_misc.c needs changes.

you fixed this.

>  Started and in progress:
>  ------------------------
>  - port sym53c8xx hppa changes forward (helge)
>  - push STI changes upstream (helge)
>  - Look at Config.help too. (tbone, HIL -> helge?)
>  - send tulip changes to jgarzik (grant)

done.

>  - switching Harmony to ALSA (laurent)

nearly done.

>  - oprofile support (tausq)

done? Seems like it's working but has a bug.

thanks,
grant

Re: [parisc-linux] 2.5 status update 2003-01-14

[Randolph Chung]

> >  - oprofile support (tausq)
> 
> done? Seems like it's working but has a bug.

well, not really. the stuff in cvs now will compile but not work. i have
local changes to make it work (modulo some bugs), but it requires some 
core changes. i'm working with the oprofile developers to get those 
changes incorporated first.

randolph
-- 
Randolph Chung
Debian GNU/Linux Developer, hppa/ia64 ports
http://www.tausq.org/

Re: [parisc-linux] 2.5 status update 2003-01-14

[Helge Deller]

Hi Matthew,

some comments from me too:

On Tuesday 14 January 2003 16:54, Matthew Wilcox wrote:
>  - Helge went completely nuts on drivers/video ;-)

:-)

> The largest chunks of that are:
>
> -rw-r--r--    1 willy    willy      166953 Jan 12 07:54 parisc-hil.diff
> -rw-r--r--    1 willy    willy      151345 Jan 12 07:47 parisc-video.diff
>
> I'm not worried about drivers/video; Helge's doing a great job staying
> synchronised with James Simmons' fb tree and that artificially inflates
> that diff.

Correct. I'll continue to feed James with our changes, so next time
when Linus syncs, we should be done.

> I am a little worried about the HIL keyboard/mouse/etc.  If someone could
> step up to take care of making them work in 2.5 and generally look after
> them, that'd be great.

It's on my todo-list, but sadly I'm currently a little too much busy with
my day-job. I'll hope to find some time in the next 10 days to look closer at this.

> Status:
> -------
>  - Merged to 2.5.58
>  - 2.5.57 booted on A500.  712 has serial problems.
>  - 2.5.56 booted on A500, 712

2.5.58-pa2 booted on 715/64

> Todo:
> -----
>  - Serial code not working for c3000 (helge)

Sadly my c3000 is completely broken, so I won't be able to test it anymore.

>  - Some options still need Kconfig help entries

Maybe some of our native english speakers could jump in here ?

>  - drivers/char/keyboard.c:987:2: warning: #warning "Cannot generate
> rawmode keyboard for your architecture yet."

I might look at this...

>  - our PDC early debug console hacks need to be cleaned up somehow

... and this too.

BTW, what happened to our IODC-Console ?????

>  - fix HIL problem: ksoftirqd eats 100% cpu (kernel 2.4; kernel 2.5?)

I'll try to look at this too.

>  - proc files are b0rken (interrupts), possible irqi funcs related pb.

pa64:~# cat /proc/interrupts 
           CPU00 
 32:     108092      PARISC-CPU  timer
 33:      13183      PARISC-CPU  lasi
 39:    1122504      PARISC-CPU  wax
 86:      11647            Lasi  lasi710
 87:        969            Lasi  i82596
 90:        569            Lasi  serial
125:          0             Wax  HP SDC NMI
126:    1122503             Wax  HP SDC

pa64:~# uname -a
Linux pa64 2.5.58-pa2 #349 Tue Jan 14 23:00:41 CET 2003 parisc unknown unknown GNU/Linux

I think I fixed that 1-2 weeks ago.

> - kernel module loader support

YES, PLEASE !


>  Started and in progress:
>  ------------------------
>  - port sym53c8xx hppa changes forward (helge)

I can't continue here, maybe some can take over and look if it's still necessary ?

>  - port hil_kbd.c to new input layer
>  - port hil_ptr.c to new input layer

belongs to HIL stuff.


Helge