Re: [PATCH v4 0/2] s390/vfio-ap: fix memory leak in mdev remove callback

[Christian Borntraeger <borntraeger@de.ibm.com>]

On 21.05.21 21:36, Tony Krowiak wrote:
> Fixes a memory leak in the mdev remove callback when invoked while the
> mdev is in use by a KVM guest. Instead of returning -EBUSY from the
> callback, a full cleanup of the resources allocated to the mdev is
> performed because regardless of the value returned from the function, the
> mdev is removed from sysfs.
> 
> The cleanup of resources allocated to the mdev may coincide with the
> interception of the PQAP(AQIC) instruction in which case data needed to
> handle the interception may get removed. A patch is included in this series
> to synchronize access to resources needed by the interception handler to
> protect against invalid memory accesses.
> 
> The first pass (PATCH v3) at trying to synchronize access to the pqap
> function pointer employed RCU. The problem is, the RCU read-side critical
> section would have to include the execution of the pqap function which
> sleeps; RCU disallows sleeping inside an RCU region. When I subsequently
> tried to encompass the pqap function within the
> rcu_read_lock/rcu_read_unlock, I ended up seeing lockdep warnings in the
> syslog.
> 
> It was suggested that we use an rw_semaphore to synchronize access to
> the pqap hook, but I also ran into similar lockdep complaints something
> like the following:
> 
>    Possible unsafe locking scenario:
> 
>          CPU0                            CPU1
>          ----                            ----
>     down_read(&rwsem)
>     in handle_pqap (priv.c);
>     
>                                    lock(&matrix_dev->lock);
>                                    in vfio_ap_mdev_set_kvm (vfio_ap_ops.c)
>                                  
>                                    down_write(&rwsem;
>                                    in vfio_ap_mdev_set_kvm (vfio_ap_ops.c)
>                                  
>     lock(&matrix_dev->lock);
>     in handle_pqap(vfio_ap_ops.c)
> 
> Access to the mdev must be done under the matrix_dev->lock to ensure that
> it doesn't get freed via the remove callback while in use. This appears
> to be mutually exclusive with setting/unsetting the pqap_hook pointer
> due to lockdep issues.
> 
> The solution:
> ------------
> The lifetime of the handle_pqap function (vfio_ap_ops) is syncrhonous
> with the lifetime of the vfio_ap module, so there really is not reason
> to tie the setting/clearing of its function pointer with the lifetime
> of a guest or even an mdev. If the function pointer is set when the
> vfio_ap module is loaded and cleared when the vfio_ap module is unloaded,
> then access to it can be protected independently from mdev creation or
> removal as well as the starting or shutdown of a guest. As long as
> access to the mdev is always controlled by the matrix_dev->lock, the
> mdev can not be freed without other functions being aware.
> 
> Change log:
> v3 -> v4:
> --------
> * Created a registry for crypto hooks in priv.c with functions for
>    registering/unregistering function pointers in kvm_host.h (for s390).
> 
> * Register the function pointer for handling the PQAP instruction when
>    the vfio_ap module is loaded and unregister it when the module is
>    unloaded.

Was there a v5? I cannot find it.