Sound problems in 2.3.50

Sound problems in 2.3.50

[Dave Caswell]

I've got no sound in 2.3.50.

My Toshiba notebook has a OPL3-SA3 chip which was working with
kernel 2.3.49 sound drivers built into the kernel.  

With 2.3.50, none of the sound devices including /dev/sndstat worked.

After checking the log files, I saw the warning that the opl3sa2
parameters needed to be set, I added an append line to my lilo.conf.
Mar 10 11:39:02 krypton kernel: ad1848/cs4248 codec driver Copyright (C) by Hannu Savolainen 1993-1996 
Mar 10 11:39:02 krypton kernel: MSS: I/O port conflict 
Mar 10 11:39:02 krypton kernel: mpu401: I/O port ffffffff already in use 
Mar 10 11:39:02 krypton kernel:  
Mar 10 11:39:02 krypton kernel: opl3sa2: io, mss_io, irq, dma, and dma2 must be set. 

Added to lilo.conf:
append = "opl3sa2=0x370,5,1,0,0x530,0x330"

Still no sound functions. So I checked the log again:

Mar 10 13:39:56 krypton kernel: ad1848/cs4248 codec driver Copyright (C) by Hannu Savolainen 1993-1996 
Mar 10 13:39:56 krypton kernel: MSS: I/O port conflict 
Mar 10 13:39:56 krypton kernel: mpu401: I/O port ffffffff already in use 
Mar 10 13:39:56 krypton kernel:  
Mar 10 13:39:56 krypton kernel: Found OPL3-SA3 (YMF715) 
Mar 10 13:39:56 krypton kernel: ad1848: must give I/O , IRQ and DMA. 

and added this to my lilo.conf
append = "ad1848=0x388,5,1,0,0"

Still no sound, although I did have some mixer settings now.

Here's what /dev/sndstat claims, with my 2.3.49 kernel.

OSS/Free:3.8s2++-971130
Load type: Driver compiled into kernel
Kernel: Linux krypton 2.3.49 #15 Fri Mar 3 10:49:22 MST 2000 i586
Config options: 0

Installed drivers: 
Type 42: OPL3SA2
Type 45: OPL3SA2 MSS
Type 43: OPL3SA2 MIDI
Type 5: Roland MPU-401
Type 26: MPU-401 (UART)

Card config: 
OPL3SA2 at 0x370 irq 5 drq 1,0
OPL3SA2 MSS at 0x530 irq 5 drq 1,0
OPL3SA2 MIDI at 0x330 irq 5 drq 1

Audio devices:
0: MS Sound System (CS4231) (DUPLEX)

Synth devices:

Midi devices:
0: MPU-401 0.0  Midi interface #1

Timers:
0: System clock
1: MS Sound System (CS4231)

Mixers:
0: OPL3-SA3 and AD1848 (through MSS)
1: MS Sound System (CS4231)

So, is there a new configuration file that I need to tweak? Or is
something broken?

Thanks for your help,
	dave caswell
	davec@apocalypse.org

Re: Sound problems in 2.3.50

[Scott Murray]

On Fri, 10 Mar 2000, Dave Caswell wrote:

> 
> I've got no sound in 2.3.50.
> 
> My Toshiba notebook has a OPL3-SA3 chip which was working with
> kernel 2.3.49 sound drivers built into the kernel.  
> 
> With 2.3.50, none of the sound devices including /dev/sndstat worked.
[snip]

Well, Christoph Hellwig is apparently adapting the sound drivers to the
newer module initialization scheme, which should make it easier to just
configure drivers into the kernel.  An additional change was the removal
of /dev/sndstat and /proc/sound, so that explains that part of the problem.

> So, is there a new configuration file that I need to tweak? Or is
> something broken?

Well, from what I can tell, your opl3sa2 append line for lilo.conf should
have gotten things working, but there was some talk of general sound issues
with 2.3.50 on linux-kernel.  Could you try 2.3.51 and see if that works?
It contains a bunch more patches to the sound system.

Scott



-- 
======================================Scott Murray                                        email: scott@spiteful.org
http://www.interlog.com/~scottm                       ICQ: 10602428
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
     "Good, bad ... I'm the guy with the gun." - Ash, "Army of Darkness"

Re: Sound problems in 2.3.50

[Dave Caswell]

>Well, Christoph Hellwig is apparently adapting the sound drivers to the
>newer module initialization scheme, which should make it easier to just
>configure drivers into the kernel.  An additional change was the removal
>of /dev/sndstat and /proc/sound, so that explains that part of the problem.

How come /proc/sound was removed?  Is there an alternative place to get
that information?

>Well, from what I can tell, your opl3sa2 append line for lilo.conf should
>have gotten things working, but there was some talk of general sound issues
>with 2.3.50 on linux-kernel.  Could you try 2.3.51 and see if that works?
>It contains a bunch more patches to the sound system.

I've been watching for sound articles on linux-kernel, and looks like
there are changes in 2.3.51 which may effect my problem. But sadly,
2.3.51 wont build on my system, so I'm just waiting for next week and
2.3.52, or 2.4-pre-1, or whatever.   When I get a new kenel built,
I'll report back.

Thanks,

	dave caswell