2.4.6 and netboot

2.4.6 and netboot

[Wakko Warner]

I'm using a kernel that is dd'd to a floppy to net boot linux on random
machines.  I noticed that 2.4.6 won't get it's IP from the server (it won't
even attempt it).  2.4.4 works

If any more info is needed, just ask.

-- 
 Lab tests show that use of micro$oft causes cancer in lab animals

Re: 2.4.6 and netboot

[Ryan Sweet]

On Thu, 19 Jul 2001, Wakko Warner wrote:

> I'm using a kernel that is dd'd to a floppy to net boot linux on random
> machines.  I noticed that 2.4.6 won't get it's IP from the server (it won't
> even attempt it).  2.4.4 works
> 
> If any more info is needed, just ask.

It sounds as though you left out CONFIG_IP_PNP in the kernel
configuration.  netboot works fine under 2.4.6 for me....


-- 
Ryan Sweet <ryan.sweet@atosorigin.com>
Atos Origin Engineering Services
http://www.aoes.nl

Re: 2.4.6 and netboot

[Joshua Schmidlkofer]

On Thursday 19 July 2001 06:26 am, Wakko Warner wrote:
> I'm using a kernel that is dd'd to a floppy to net boot linux on random
> machines.  I noticed that 2.4.6 won't get it's IP from the server (it won't
> even attempt it).  2.4.4 works
>
> If any more info is needed, just ask.

Sine 2.4.4 I have been unable to make ipconfig automagically go, and I think 
that this configuration is not supported.   At least, with my limited 
knowledge of how ipconfig works  you must to pass: 'ipconfig=dhcp', or 
ipconfig='bootp' to the kernel at boot time.  I built a LILO disk, but
I think that syslinux would work.  Also, I did eventually successfully get an 
Xterminal running.

After 2.4.4 ipconfig was changed to the ipconfig= style of behaviour.  I 
don't know why, but someone does.  I think it has to do with implementation 
cahnges to allow for modularized NIC's to use ipautoconfig.   This seems 
insane that functionality was cut in order to do this.

Also, I have been unable to make bootp work for nfsboot, but I suspect my 
bootp server - not the kernel.

BACK to the point.  Since 2.4.5 I have had to use lilo, and add a line that 
says 'nfs=[all that stuff] ipconfig=dhcp'

good luck.

js

Re: 2.4.6 and netboot

[Wakko Warner]

> > I'm using a kernel that is dd'd to a floppy to net boot linux on random
> > machines.  I noticed that 2.4.6 won't get it's IP from the server (it won't
> > even attempt it).  2.4.4 works
> > 
> > If any more info is needed, just ask.
> 
> It sounds as though you left out CONFIG_IP_PNP in the kernel
> configuration.  netboot works fine under 2.4.6 for me....

# grep CONFIG_IP_PNP /usr/src/linux/wdist/2.4.6/.config       
CONFIG_IP_PNP=y
# CONFIG_IP_PNP_DHCP is not set
CONFIG_IP_PNP_BOOTP=y
# CONFIG_IP_PNP_RARP is not set
#

Nope, didn't.  2.4.4 works just fine, 2.4.6 doesn't.  I also have no way of
doing kernel parameters since it's a raw kernel.

-- 
 Lab tests show that use of micro$oft causes cancer in lab animals

Re: 2.4.6 and netboot

[Wakko Warner]

> On Thursday 19 July 2001 06:26 am, Wakko Warner wrote:
> > I'm using a kernel that is dd'd to a floppy to net boot linux on random
> > machines.  I noticed that 2.4.6 won't get it's IP from the server (it won't
> > even attempt it).  2.4.4 works
> >
> > If any more info is needed, just ask.
> 
> Sine 2.4.4 I have been unable to make ipconfig automagically go, and I think 
> that this configuration is not supported.   At least, with my limited 
> knowledge of how ipconfig works  you must to pass: 'ipconfig=dhcp', or 
> ipconfig='bootp' to the kernel at boot time.  I built a LILO disk, but
> I think that syslinux would work.  Also, I did eventually successfully get an 
> Xterminal running.

> After 2.4.4 ipconfig was changed to the ipconfig= style of behaviour.  I 
> don't know why, but someone does.  I think it has to do with implementation 
> cahnges to allow for modularized NIC's to use ipautoconfig.   This seems 
> insane that functionality was cut in order to do this.

Hmm, maybe I'll check the diff on 2.4.5 to see what was done.

> Also, I have been unable to make bootp work for nfsboot, but I suspect my 
> bootp server - not the kernel.
> 
> BACK to the point.  Since 2.4.5 I have had to use lilo, and add a line that 
> says 'nfs=[all that stuff] ipconfig=dhcp'

=(

-- 
 Lab tests show that use of micro$oft causes cancer in lab animals