Bug with netfilter and NFS server on same machine

Bug with netfilter and NFS server on same machine

[Lars Knudsen]

I have been experiencing problems running a nfs server and iptables on 
the same machine.The problem was also reported almost a year ago by Paul 
Raines 
http://lists.netfilter.org/pipermail/netfilter/2002-January/030002.html 
but it seems no solution has been found yet.

The problem is this: A machine running linux 2.4.18 or 2.4.19 works just 
fine when running just the kernel nfsd. A single client connected to the 
server with 100Mbit ethernet sees throughput of 5-10MByte/sec even after 
an hour or two of continous transfers. If the nfs server is also running 
iptables the throughput is initially the same (5-10MByte/sec) but after 
a while (200MByte-500MByte total transfer) the client starts reporting 
"nfs server not responding" followed after a while by "nfs server OK" 
and of course the transfer rate goes way down (< 1MByte/sec). Using 
tcpdump on the client seems to indicate that some packets have their 
headers garbled - wrong fragment ids being the typical error.

Having iptables compiled as modules and simply loading or unloading the 
ipt_conntrack module is
sufficient for causing/removing the problem. Having iptables support 
compiled into the kernel causes the problem allways.

The problem has been verified on 4 different machines with a variety of 
different ethernet cards. In
all cases the network continues to work without problems for all other 
types of traffic - i.e a telnet connection from client to server works 
with no delay and a ftp transfer goes at >5MByte/sec even when nfs 
throughput is suffering.

\Lars Knudsen

Re: Bug with netfilter and NFS server on same machine

[Luciano Ruete]

Lars Knudsen escribió::
> I have been experiencing problems running a nfs server and iptables on 
> (...)
> The problem has been verified on 4 different machines with a variety of 
> different ethernet cards. In
> all cases the network continues to work without problems for all other 
> types of traffic - i.e a telnet connection from client to server works 
> with no delay and a ftp transfer goes at >5MByte/sec even when nfs 
> throughput is suffering.

I sugest that you send this to linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org

--
Luciano