[U-Boot] SoCFPGA PL330 DMA driver and ECC scrubbing

[Jason Rush <jarush@gmail.com>]

On 6/29/2018 9:52 AM, Marek Vasut wrote:
> On 06/29/2018 04:44 PM, Jason Rush wrote:
>> On 6/29/2018 9:34 AM, Marek Vasut wrote:
>>> On 06/29/2018 04:31 PM, Jason Rush wrote:
>>>> Dinh,
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>>> A while ago, you posted the following patchset for SoCFPGA to add the PL330
>>>> DMA driver, and updated the SoCFPGA SDRAM init to write zeros to SDRAM to
>>>> initialize the ECC bits if ECC was enabled:
>>>>
>>>> https://lists.denx.de/pipermail/u-boot/2016-October/269643.html
>>>>
>>>> I know it's been a long time, so I'll summarize some of the conversation...
>>>>
>>>> At the time, you had a problem with the patchset causing the SPL to fail to
>>>> find the MMC.  You had tracked it down to an issue with the following commit
>>>> "a78cd8613204 ARM: Rework and correct barrier definitions".  You and Marek
>>>> discussed it a bit, but I don't think there was a real conclusion.  You
>>>> submitted a second version of the patchset asking for advice on debugging
>>>> the issue:
>>>>
>>>> https://lists.denx.de/pipermail/u-boot/2016-December/275822.html
>>>>
>>>> No real conversation came from the second patchset, and that was the end of
>>>> the patch.
>>>>
>>>> I was hoping we could revisit adding your patchset again. I am working on a
>>>> custom SoCFPGA board with a Cyclone V and ECC SDRAM. I rebased your patchset
>>>> against v2018.05 and it is working on my custom board (although I don't have
>>>> an MMC). I also tested it on a SoCKit booting from an MMC (I forced it to
>>>> scrub the SDRAM on the SoCKit, because it doesn't have ECC RAM), and the
>>>> SoCKit finds the MMC and boots.
>>>>
>>>> I don't have any suggestions on why it is working now on my board and not
>>>> back when you first submitted the patchset.  Maybe something else was fixed
>>>> in the MMC? I was hoping you and Marek could test this patch again on some
>>>> different SoCFPGA boards to see if you get the same results.
>>> Look at this patch
>>> http://git.denx.de/?p=u-boot/u-boot-socfpga.git;a=commit;h=9bb8a249b292d26f152c20e3641600b3d7b3924b
>>>
>>> You likely want similar approach, it's faster then the DMA and much simpler.
>>>
>> Thanks Marek.  I'll give it a try.  Would you be interested in a similar patch for the Gen 5?
> I don't have any Gen5 board which uses ECC, do you ?
> If so, yes, prepare a patch, it should be very similar.
>
> Make sure to measure how long it takes to scrub the memory and how much
> memory you have, I'd be interested in the numbers.
>
Looking at the master branch, it doesn't look like that code is ever being called?
The sdram_init_ecc_bits() function is called from the ddr_calibration_sequence function(),
but I can't find where ddr_calibration_sequence is called().

Either way, I can test it. I have a custom Cyclone V board with ECC, and the Intel Arria V SoC
Dev Kit I can test it on too which I think has ECC.