Problems with voice call.

Problems with voice call.

[Marko Saukko]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 947 bytes --]

Hi,

I'm trying to make a voice call with oFono. I'm using Option GlobeSurfer
ICON 225 HSDPA/UMTS USB as the modem. If I understood correctly voice
call should be possible with the dbus-messages used below. However, I
end up with an error "Operation failed".

$ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /
org.ofono.at.Manager.Create string:"dev:/dev/ttyHS0" string:"at"
method return sender=:1.540 -> dest=:1.544 reply_serial=2
   object path "/modem1"

$ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /modem1
org.ofono.VoiceCallManager.Dial string:"+000000000000" string:"default"
Error org.ofono.Error.Failed: Operation failed

When the second dbus-message is sent the following messages are printed
by the ofonod:

ofonod[19113]: atd_cb got result: 0
ofonod[19113]: Final response: ERROR
ofonod[19113]: Dial callback returned error: (null)

Are the messages I sent to the ofonod correct?

Regards,
Marko

RE: Problems with voice call.

[Li, Zhigang]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1819 bytes --]

Hi Marko,

>-----Original Message-----
>From: ofono-bounces(a)ofono.org [mailto:ofono-bounces(a)ofono.org] On Behalf Of
>Marko Saukko
>Sent: 2009年7月13日 14:13
>To: ofono(a)ofono.org
>Subject: Problems with voice call.
>
>Hi,
>
>I'm trying to make a voice call with oFono. I'm using Option GlobeSurfer
>ICON 225 HSDPA/UMTS USB as the modem. If I understood correctly voice
>call should be possible with the dbus-messages used below. However, I
>end up with an error "Operation failed".


Yes, it can use dbus-message but python script will be more visibility
Also you can try use d-feet 
As I haven't modem in hand so I use phonesim as simulator, I didn't meet your problem and the Voice call work fine with simulator 

>
>$ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /
>org.ofono.at.Manager.Create string:"dev:/dev/ttyHS0" string:"at"
>method return sender=:1.540 -> dest=:1.544 reply_serial=2
>   object path "/modem1"
>
>$ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /modem1
>org.ofono.VoiceCallManager.Dial string:"+000000000000" string:"default"
>Error org.ofono.Error.Failed: Operation failed


My result:
dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /modem1 org.ofono.VoiceCallManager.Dial string:"+234" string:"default" 
method return sender=:1.829 -> dest=:1.851 reply_serial=2
   object path "/modem1/voicecall01"

>
>When the second dbus-message is sent the following messages are printed
>by the ofonod:
>
>ofonod[19113]: atd_cb got result: 0
>ofonod[19113]: Final response: ERROR
>ofonod[19113]: Dial callback returned error: (null)
>
>Are the messages I sent to the ofonod correct?
>
So you can check if your modem could receive the ATD command first.
If not, perhaps something wrong in driver part.

>Regards,
>Marko

Zhigang

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Marcel Holtmann]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 431 bytes --]

Hi Marko,

> I'm trying to make a voice call with oFono. I'm using Option GlobeSurfer
> ICON 225 HSDPA/UMTS USB as the modem. If I understood correctly voice
> call should be possible with the dbus-messages used below. However, I
> end up with an error "Operation failed".

I am not sure this hardware actually does support voice calls. We
haven't tried it. So it is up to you to figure this out.

Regards

Marcel

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Denis Kenzior]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1255 bytes --]

Hi Marko,

> Hi,
>
> I'm trying to make a voice call with oFono. I'm using Option GlobeSurfer
> ICON 225 HSDPA/UMTS USB as the modem. If I understood correctly voice
> call should be possible with the dbus-messages used below. However, I
> end up with an error "Operation failed".

Operation failed literally means the modem replied with an error of some sort.

>
> $ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /
> org.ofono.at.Manager.Create string:"dev:/dev/ttyHS0" string:"at"
> method return sender=:1.540 -> dest=:1.544 reply_serial=2
>    object path "/modem1"

Looks good.

>
> $ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /modem1
> org.ofono.VoiceCallManager.Dial string:"+000000000000" string:"default"
> Error org.ofono.Error.Failed: Operation failed

For wrong arguments, the error would be something like InvalidArguments or 
InvalidFormat.

>
> When the second dbus-message is sent the following messages are printed
> by the ofonod:
>
> ofonod[19113]: atd_cb got result: 0
> ofonod[19113]: Final response: ERROR
> ofonod[19113]: Dial callback returned error: (null)

This means that ATD final response was ERROR.  Are you sure your modem actually 
supports voice calls?

Regards,
-Denis

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Marko Saukko]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 709 bytes --]

Hi denkenz,

thanks for the reply. I was not sure about the voice call features of
the modem. Now when I searched the answer I found out that the modem
does not in fact support voice calls.

I did not realize this at first, because ofono offered the possibility
for voice calls (loaded for example the VoiceCallManager interface). For
SMS ofonod says

ofonod[7906]: SMS not supported by this modem.  If this is in error
please submit patches to support this hardware

however the modem has a support for SMS, which I also tested with the
windows drivers that were delivered with the modem.

Maybe there could be similar "not supported" feature for the voice call
plugins?

Regards,
Marko

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Marcel Holtmann]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 916 bytes --]

Hi Marko,

> thanks for the reply. I was not sure about the voice call features of
> the modem. Now when I searched the answer I found out that the modem
> does not in fact support voice calls.
> 
> I did not realize this at first, because ofono offered the possibility
> for voice calls (loaded for example the VoiceCallManager interface). For
> SMS ofonod says
> 
> ofonod[7906]: SMS not supported by this modem.  If this is in error
> please submit patches to support this hardware
> 
> however the modem has a support for SMS, which I also tested with the
> windows drivers that were delivered with the modem.
> 
> Maybe there could be similar "not supported" feature for the voice call
> plugins?

we need better hardware detection and enumeration and might have to add
detailed feature mask to each modem. So we can tell if such a modem
supports voice calls etc.

Regards

Marcel

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Denis Kenzior]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1703 bytes --]

Hi Marko,

> Hi denkenz,
>
> thanks for the reply. I was not sure about the voice call features of
> the modem. Now when I searched the answer I found out that the modem
> does not in fact support voice calls.

Yes, oFono's current implementation does not understand hardware specifics.  
The current atmodem driver assumes a fully featured modem with perfect fluency 
in 27.007 & 27.005.  Obviously this is wrong for real modems.  Mostly this is 
because we were concentrating on getting the high level features working, 
before delving into hardware specifics.

>
> I did not realize this at first, because ofono offered the possibility
> for voice calls (loaded for example the VoiceCallManager interface). For
> SMS ofonod says
>
> ofonod[7906]: SMS not supported by this modem.  If this is in error
> please submit patches to support this hardware
>
> however the modem has a support for SMS, which I also tested with the
> windows drivers that were delivered with the modem.
>

I've seen this reported at least twice now.  Which means that my SMS support 
detection in atmodem driver is probably not quite correct.  Would you be able 
to report at which point in the drivers/atmodem/sms.c initialization that this 
fails?

> Maybe there could be similar "not supported" feature for the voice call
> plugins?

27.005 defines at least some rudimentary way to detect whether SMS is supported 
by the modem or not.  Unfortunately 27.007 doesn't have an equivalent for 
voice calls.  The generic driver will do its best to figure out what is 
supported or not supported, but it will be up to the device-specific driver to 
have the final say.

Regards,
-Denis

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Marko Saukko]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1647 bytes --]

Hi Denis,

>
> I've seen this reported at least twice now.  Which means that my SMS support
> detection in atmodem driver is probably not quite correct.  Would you be able
> to report at which point in the drivers/atmodem/sms.c initialization that this
> fails?
>

With the Option iCON 225 USB modem the SMS error is sent in function
at_cmgf_query_cb() at line 795.

795                 return at_sms_not_supported(modem);

This is because the mode variable is always set to 0 at line 788
(while loop is executed only onces) and the supported stays at value FALSE:

788                 while (g_at_result_iter_next_number(&iter, &mode))
789                         if (mode == 1)
790                                 supported = TRUE;



I also tested oFono with the Nokia E51 phone which if I have understood
correctly supports of sending SMS messages at least on Windows
with PC Suite software. The result is a bit different.

With E51 the SMS error is returned from function at_cpms_query_cb()
on line 764.

764                 return at_sms_not_supported(modem);

This is because it does not go inside the while loop starting at line 741,
and the me_supported and sm_supported stays FALSE:

740
741                         while (g_at_result_iter_next_string(&iter, &store)) {
742                                 if (!strcmp(store, "ME"))
743                                         me_supported[mem] = TRUE;
744                                 else if (!strcmp(store, "SM"))
745                                         sm_supported[mem] = TRUE;
746                         }
747


Regards,
Marko

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Denis Kenzior]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 653 bytes --]

Hi Marko,

> 788                 while (g_at_result_iter_next_number(&iter, &mode))
> 789                         if (mode == 1)
> 790                                 supported = TRUE;

This is me being dyslexic.  It should be looking for mode == 0 instead.

> With E51 the SMS error is returned from function at_cpms_query_cb()
> on line 764.
>
> 764                 return at_sms_not_supported(modem);
>

This is strange, what does the E51 return for "AT+CPMS=?"

I've pushed fixes to the initialization and this is working at least for the 
Neo and on our simulator.  Can you report if your devices get further?

Regards,
-Denis

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Marko Saukko]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1093 bytes --]

Hi Denis,

With Option iCON 225 the SMS service started to work and I was also able
to send SMS message with the following command:

$ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /modem1
org.ofono.SmsManager.SendMessage array:string:"+358000000000"
string:"ofono test message"


The Nokia E51 returns still the SMS error thing. To AT+CPMS=? the E51
returns the following:
+CPMS: (),(),()

OK

There is also following errors printed by the ofonod when modem is
created with E51:

...
ofonod[14999]: at_crsm_info_cb got result: 0
ofonod[14999]: Final response: ERROR
ofonod[14999]: cops_numeric_cb got result: 1
...
ofonod[14999]: at_crsm_info_cb got result: 0
ofonod[14999]: Final response: ERROR
ofonod[14999]: cmgf_query_cb got result: 1
...
ofonod[14999]: at_crsm_info_cb got result: 0
ofonod[14999]: Final response: ERROR
ofonod[14999]: cpms_query_cb got result: 1
ofonod[14999]: Response line: +CPMS: (),(),()
ofonod[14999]: SMS not supported by this modem.  If this is in error
please submit patches to support this hardware



Regards,
Marko

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Juha Korpi]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1752 bytes --]

Hi,

I am using Nokia 6021 and there seems to be same problem(I guess):

ofonod[8320]: at_cpms_query_cb got result: 1
ofonod[8320]: Final response: OK
ofonod[8320]: Response line: +CPMS: ("ME","SM"),("ME","SM"),("MT")
ofonod[8320]: at_cpms_query_cb
ofonod[8320]: SMS not supported by this modem.  If this is in error  
please submit patches to support this hardware
-- 
Juha Korpi


Lainaus Marko Saukko <marko.saukko@gmail.com>:

> Hi Denis,
>
> With Option iCON 225 the SMS service started to work and I was also able
> to send SMS message with the following command:
>
> $ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /modem1
> org.ofono.SmsManager.SendMessage array:string:"+358000000000"
> string:"ofono test message"
>
>
> The Nokia E51 returns still the SMS error thing. To AT+CPMS=? the E51
> returns the following:
> +CPMS: (),(),()
>
> OK
>
> There is also following errors printed by the ofonod when modem is
> created with E51:
>
> ...
> ofonod[14999]: at_crsm_info_cb got result: 0
> ofonod[14999]: Final response: ERROR
> ofonod[14999]: cops_numeric_cb got result: 1
> ...
> ofonod[14999]: at_crsm_info_cb got result: 0
> ofonod[14999]: Final response: ERROR
> ofonod[14999]: cmgf_query_cb got result: 1
> ...
> ofonod[14999]: at_crsm_info_cb got result: 0
> ofonod[14999]: Final response: ERROR
> ofonod[14999]: cpms_query_cb got result: 1
> ofonod[14999]: Response line: +CPMS: (),(),()
> ofonod[14999]: SMS not supported by this modem.  If this is in error
> please submit patches to support this hardware
>
>
>
> Regards,
> Marko
> _______________________________________________
> ofono mailing list
> ofono(a)ofono.org
> http://lists.ofono.org/listinfo/ofono
>

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Denis Kenzior]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 720 bytes --]

Hi Marko,

> Hi Denis,
>
> With Option iCON 225 the SMS service started to work and I was also able
> to send SMS message with the following command:
>
> $ dbus-send --system --print-reply --dest=org.ofono /modem1
> org.ofono.SmsManager.SendMessage array:string:"+358000000000"
> string:"ofono test message"

Excellent.

> The Nokia E51 returns still the SMS error thing. To AT+CPMS=? the E51
> returns the following:
> +CPMS: (),(),()
>
> OK

Are you running this over bluetooth?  Perhaps this has a really cut down at 
command set in bluetooth serial profile.  The other possibility is that you 
need to send some initialization commands first, (maybe AT+CFUN=1 would do it?)

Regards,
-Denis

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Denis Kenzior]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 446 bytes --]

Hi Juha,

> I am using Nokia 6021 and there seems to be same problem(I guess):
>
> ofonod[8320]: Response line: +CPMS: ("ME","SM"),("ME","SM"),("MT")

Your problem is a bit different.  CPMS here reports:
mem1: "ME", "SM"
mem2: "ME", "SM"
mem3: "MT"

oFono was confused by "MT" setting.  I've added experimental support for such 
devices.  Please report back if oFono gets further in the initialization 
process.

Regards,
-Denis

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Juha Korpi]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 775 bytes --]

Hi Denis,

the experimental support was working fine. I was even able to send a SMS.

Thanks
Juha Korpi


Lainaus Denis Kenzior <denkenz@gmail.com>:

> Hi Juha,
>
>> I am using Nokia 6021 and there seems to be same problem(I guess):
>>
>> ofonod[8320]: Response line: +CPMS: ("ME","SM"),("ME","SM"),("MT")
>
> Your problem is a bit different.  CPMS here reports:
> mem1: "ME", "SM"
> mem2: "ME", "SM"
> mem3: "MT"
>
> oFono was confused by "MT" setting.  I've added experimental support for such
> devices.  Please report back if oFono gets further in the initialization
> process.
>
> Regards,
> -Denis
> _______________________________________________
> ofono mailing list
> ofono(a)ofono.org
> http://lists.ofono.org/listinfo/ofono
>

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Marko Saukko]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 251 bytes --]

Hi Denis,

I'm running the E51 over USB connection. The AT+CFUN=1 did not help:

AT+CFUN=1
OK
AT+CPMS=?
+CPMS: (),(),()

OK

P.S. The SMS service is also now working with Nokia 6100 (connected with
 Nokia CA-42 cable).

Regards,
Marko

Re: Problems with voice call.

[Denis Kenzior]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 489 bytes --]

Hi Marko,

> Hi Denis,
>
> I'm running the E51 over USB connection. The AT+CFUN=1 did not help:
>
> AT+CFUN=1
> OK
> AT+CPMS=?
> +CPMS: (),(),()
>
> OK

It sounds like the E51 doesn't have a proper AT command set for it to be 
supported by the generic driver.  You can try to investigate whether it still 
sends the proper +CMT or +CMTI notifications on sms delivery (see 3GPP 27.005).  
If it does, then a custom sms driver for E51 could be feasible.

Regards,
-Denis