Re: [LARTC] HTB is nor fair when 'borrowing? *bug* in HTB or some

[pljosh <witek876@interia.pl>]

U¿ytkownik Andy Furniss napisa³:
> I tried with your rc.shape script on my LAN using scp. I couldn't get 
> the bash to work - it looks to me like it will only set one user. But I 

Did you launch it passing argument in "" or ''?
./rc.shape "4 5 6"
is quite far different than
./rc.shape 4 5 6

> hardcoded my settings in it and checked with tc -s class ls dev eth0 
> that my 2 classes existed.

I dont get it: you prepared two classes for two PCs which is equivalent 
to "t5" on my graph which shows that HTB acts PERFECT in such conditions.

> I SCPd a file from gateway to 2 PCs and thay were shaped OK and came in 
> second perfect. It was the same for 500,1000 and 5000 ceils. The 500 
> test took 15 mins.
> So I don't really know whats going on for you.
> Andy.

Try the same using 3 classes and stress it with 2 PCs only (each class 
has rate=1/3 of max bw and ceil=max bw. You will se that first class 
will get from HTB almost TWICE as much as secound one one!

-josh

p.s.
I made same test on other network with other PCs and different kernel 
version and it was the same...

_______________________________________________
LARTC mailing list / LARTC@mailman.ds9a.nl
http://mailman.ds9a.nl/mailman/listinfo/lartc HOWTO: http://lartc.org/