Lower throughput in Ad-hoc than in Infrastructure mode?

Lower throughput in Ad-hoc than in Infrastructure mode?

[Floris Van den Abeele]

While running throughput experiments using iperf I noticed that UDP
throughput in ad-hoc mode was considerably lower than in Infrastructure
mode. The setups I'm comparing is a 802.11a ad-hoc network consisting of
two clients vs a 802.11a infrastructure network consisting of an access
point and a client (11a because the tests were run in the 5GHz band).

For ad-hoc mode I'm consistenly seeing a lower throughput than for
infrastructure mode: i.e. 22.4 Mbits/sec vs 28.2 Mbits/sec. Note that
while sniffing the medium radiotap headers report a PHY data rate of
54Mbit/s in both cases. There is no other traffic on the Wi-Fi channel
in question (44). Considering the medium access for both setups is
similair I would expect to find similair throughputs. Is this a known
issue with the linux wireless/mac80211/ath9k driver stack or is this
behaviour conform the 802.11 standard (based on my knowledge I would say
no to the latter)? My test specs are below.

For testing I'm using Sparklan WPEA-111N NIC's (AR9280). The nodes are
running OpenWrt attitude adjusment on r32482 (from 2012-06-21) with the
REGD patch enabled. I believe that this build of OpenWRT uses the
compat-wireless-2012-06-14.tar.bz2 drivers.

Kind regards,
Floris

-- 
Floris Van den Abeele
Department of Information Technology
Internet Based Communication Networks and Services (IBCN)
Ghent University - iMinds
Gaston Crommenlaan 8 (Bus 201), B-9050 Gent, Belgium
M: +32 (0)494 24 92 76
E: floris.vandenabeele@intec.UGent.be
W : www.ibcn.intec.UGent.be

Re: Lower throughput in Ad-hoc than in Infrastructure mode?

[Felix Fietkau]

On 2013-10-15 9:28 AM, Floris Van den Abeele wrote:
> While running throughput experiments using iperf I noticed that UDP
> throughput in ad-hoc mode was considerably lower than in Infrastructure
> mode. The setups I'm comparing is a 802.11a ad-hoc network consisting of
> two clients vs a 802.11a infrastructure network consisting of an access
> point and a client (11a because the tests were run in the 5GHz band).
> 
> For ad-hoc mode I'm consistenly seeing a lower throughput than for
> infrastructure mode: i.e. 22.4 Mbits/sec vs 28.2 Mbits/sec. Note that
> while sniffing the medium radiotap headers report a PHY data rate of
> 54Mbit/s in both cases. There is no other traffic on the Wi-Fi channel
> in question (44). Considering the medium access for both setups is
> similair I would expect to find similair throughputs. Is this a known
> issue with the linux wireless/mac80211/ath9k driver stack or is this
> behaviour conform the 802.11 standard (based on my knowledge I would say
> no to the latter)? My test specs are below.
> 
> For testing I'm using Sparklan WPEA-111N NIC's (AR9280). The nodes are
> running OpenWrt attitude adjusment on r32482 (from 2012-06-21) with the
> REGD patch enabled. I believe that this build of OpenWRT uses the
> compat-wireless-2012-06-14.tar.bz2 drivers.
I'd suggest that you try a recent version of OpenWrt before
investigating further.

- Felix