is cp0 interrupt infrastructure sufficient..?

is cp0 interrupt infrastructure sufficient..?

[ashish anand]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/html, Size: 1285 bytes --]

[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/plain, Size: 937 bytes --]

I have a generic question regarding interrupt controler functionality 
integrated in CP0 on mips architecture.
I don't see any interface to configure the edge/level triggering settings.

though in our BSP we take care of handling spurious interrupts , but is
this designed to be like that..?

I mean to ask , suppose I want to add a edge triggering peripheral 
, to the extent of my understanding this will certainly generate the
spurious interrupts when coupled with a level triggering configuration 
in CP0 (by default..?).

if i am handling through CP0_CAUSE or any other register inspection
that can work but I am loosing so many valid interupts which would have been really valid with edge trigger pin of interrupt controller  .
further this type of handling is valid for actual spurious interrupts 
not for those who are certain to be fired because of edge/level mismatching.

Best Regards,
Ashish Anand

Re: is cp0 interrupt infrastructure sufficient..?

[Ralf Baechle]

On Mon, Nov 17, 2003 at 11:40:11AM -0000, ashish  anand wrote:

> I have a generic question regarding interrupt controler functionality 
> integrated in CP0 on mips architecture.
> I don't see any interface to configure the edge/level triggering settings.

MIPS only supports level triggered interrupts in coprocessor 0.

> though in our BSP we take care of handling spurious interrupts , but is
> this designed to be like that..?

There is no handling needed.  If the processor takes an interrupt but none
of the interrupt bits in c0_status is set, just return.  That's a legal
condition.

> I mean to ask , suppose I want to add a edge triggering peripheral.
> to the extent of my understanding this will certainly generate the
> spurious interrupts when coupled with a level triggering configuration 
> in CP0 (by default..?).

You can directly sample the level of the edge irq in the interrupt bits in
the cause register.  But that seems a fragile approach.

> if i am handling through CP0_CAUSE or any other register inspection
> that can work but I am loosing so many valid interupts which would have
> been really valid with edge trigger pin of interrupt controller  .
> further this type of handling is valid for actual spurious interrupts 
> not for those who are certain to be fired because of edge/level mismatching.

If you really need to use an edge triggered interrupt on a MIPS then you
probably want to use some circuit interrupt controller that converts the
edge to a level triggered interrupt.  

  Ralf