Re: [PATCH 1/2] x86/cpu/hygon: Introduce macros for hygon family numbers

[Ingo Molnar <mingo@kernel.org>]

* Chaohong Guo <guochaohong@open-hieco.net> wrote:

> Consolidate all magic numbers of hygon CPUs into a header file,
> The macros describe the family/model numbers of hygon CPUs.

> +#define	HFM(_family, _model)	VFM_MAKE(X86_VENDOR_HYGON, _family, _model)
> +
> +#define	HYGON_F18_M04		HFM(0x18, 4)
> +#define	HYGON_F18_M06		HFM(0x18, 6)
> +#define	HYGON_F18_M07		HFM(0x18, 7)
> +
> +
> +#define	HYGON_7447V		HYGON_F18_M07

So this is a bit misleading, AFAICT "7447V" is the enterprise server
CPU variant - but there's a bunch of smaller server and desktop
CPU variants as well that are named differently:

	Model Name	Core / Thread Count	Base Clock	Target Segment
	----------      ----------------------  ----------      -------------
	7447V		96 Cores / 192 Threads	~2.6 GHz	Enterprise / Cloud Server
	7490H		96 Cores / 192 Threads	—		High-Density Server
	7490		64 Cores / 128 Threads	2.7 GHz		Enterprise Server
	7470		48 Cores /  96 Threads	—		Enterprise Server
	3490		16 Cores /  32 Threads	2.8 GHz		Desktop / Workstation
	3450E		 8 Cores /  16 Threads	3.6 GHz		Workstation / Desktop
	3450G		 8 Cores /  16 Threads	2.7 GHz		Workstation / Desktop

Assuming that this patch does the right thing for all
these smaller variants as well (does it?), shouldn't
the name be something like HYGON_4G or so, given
that the patch applies to the 4th generation Hygon
microarchitecture, not a specific server CPU configuration
such as 7447V?

Thanks,

	Ingo