Re: can device drivers return non-ram via vm_ops->nopage?

[Benjamin Herrenschmidt <benh@kernel.crashing.org>]

Well, I just went over this whole discussion and I think it's just
going to hell.

So here are my 2 cents of suggestions:

 - We _WANT_ the ability to map coherent memory to userspace, that's
the normal way to map sound buffers to userland for low latency (though
mapping the actual DMA ptrs is a different matter and is definitely not
working with a bunch of sound interfaces). This is also necessary for
the infiniband/myrinet kind of things. DRI sort-of need that when not
using AGP, AGP itself is a special case but could be considered as
coherent memory in some platforms too (and will be with PCI Express
afaik) etc...

 - Some architectures apparently cannot do that (parisc ?)

 - Too bad for them... They won't have low latency audio and fast
networking and be done with it. Let's implement a couple of simple
to use (driver-wise) helpers

   dma_can_mmap_coherent() -> parisc returns false here
   dma_mmap_coherent()
   dma_mmap_coherent_sg()

And be done with it. I don't see where is the debate here ? The
API takes the same sglist as used for dma_map_sg, I don't see the
point of anything different, I agree with linus that it's not worth
even thinking about not having struct page here. 

Ben.