Re: alsactl adds volume controls?

[Clemens Ladisch <clemens@ladisch.de>]

Colin Guthrie wrote:
> 'Twas brillig, and Clemens Ladisch at 30/09/10 12:03 did gyre and gimble:
>> Colin Guthrie wrote:

>> The hardware control is always used.  The user control created by
>> softvol is used when some application is using the softvol plugin.
>> (For an application using device names like "hw" or "plughw", there will
>> be not softvol plugin.)
> 
> OK. As pulse's mixer profiles *tries* to use "front" but will fall back
> to "hw", we can be pretty much certain that the softvol plugin will
> exist in all cases. The trick is knowing whether or not the control is
> active.

used by current stream

> (although the latency of updates is terrible for me when I adjust the
> alsamixer. I guess changing PCM directly in alsamixer it doesn't trigger
> an immediate rewind in PA so the buffer has to run out for the change to
> be heard.

Yes.  The softvol plugin could be changed to try to update the already-
written part of the buffer; so far, not many programs have used big
buffers.

>>> Potential solutions would include:
>>>  1. If the "correct" solution is to just use SND_PCM_NO_AUTO in PA, and
>>> then deliberately/actively ignore any softvol mixers, then nothing needs
>>> done at the alsa level I guess.
>> 
>> Yes.
>> 
>> Use snd_ctl_elem_info_is_user() to check for the softvol mixer element.
> 
> Hmm, judging by the previous response to this suggestion, I'm not sure
> this will work:
> 
> http://mailman.alsa-project.org/pipermail/alsa-devel/2007-December/004622.html

It would have worked if PA used the snd_ctl_* instead of the snd_mixer_*
functions.

In this special case, we know that the snd_ctl control "Playback PCM
Volume" maps to the snd_mixer "PCM" playback volume, but this would
still be a hack.

>> It was decided to store this control in the hardware device so that it
>> is saved/restored together with the 'real' controls.
> 
> That as a principle makes sense but I still don't understand why it has
> to be there when it's not active.

So that it behaves like a 'real' control, i.e., you can set (and restore)
it even when nothing is currently playing.

> Also I said I'd refer back to [1] later, so here it is. I'm a little
> confused as to why it's stored in asound.state, if, as you say, the
> control is only created when something opens "front:" or similar. When
> the asound.state is read and restored during boot (this is the only time
> for 99% of users I believe - other than running it manually), would it
> not be the case that nothing has yet opened "front:" and thus it will
> not be restored?

When alsactl restores a user control, it will automatically create it.
Thus, using the softvol plugin creates this control practically
permamently.

> setting Master (not PCM) to 0% aka -46.5dB causes some kind of auto-
> mute that cuts off all sound. It shouldn't do that.

Wasn't this a hardware error?
The driver should report correct dB information for this chip.


Regards,
Clemens